Target: Still no to bell ringers, donating $1 million instead

I like The fact tha TARGET doesn't allow any solication........at any time......you go too store too buy your needs...at times it is just not right too have too say no and gives you a Guilty Feeling...Causes me to not want too go back..I love holidays...but enough is enough

I like The fact tha TARGET doesn't allow any solication........at any time......you go too store too buy your needs...at times it is just not right too have too say no and gives you a Guilty Feeling...Causes me to not want too go back..I love holidays...but enough is enough

I think Target is correct. And I am annoyed to have to listen to their stupid bells never mind that fact that they "hire" people to ring the bell that are truly a disgrace. Hey The "Army" should make sure the ringers are at least clean and well-kept. They certainly would attract more $$$$.

i will not set foot in target this christmas season. The salvation army is a wonderful orginization that truly helps people.

Target is correct to not have doors obstructed by and shoppers made to feel guilty entering their store. I might want to spend a few extra dollars for a Starbucks Coffee and relax a moment during the shopping frenzie, I have arthritis and the less delay and hassle the better, we are an aging society and at least one retailer,Target, Understands that Seniors are not there to contribute to Charity, we are the to shop and escape the solicitations we receive by phone and in the mail.

Go Target, get the job done. Make a corp contribution so your customers can concentrate on shopping

My father was an Aethist but the one charity he always wrote a large check for at this time of year was the Salvation Army. He came to this country as a teenager with no support, but the Savation Army saved his life. He never forgot, and I continue that tradition for those who will be provided for by this special group.

a $1 million donation sounds great.... but when you consider how much money The Salvation Army is losing at each location across the country... it is far more than $1 million. Thats not what I call "getting the job done". Also about hiring.... The Salvation Army "hires" folks who have no job, giving them a little extra for the holidays as well. Not to mention that most Salvation Armies do not even "hire" but only give a check for meal reimbursement. Know your facts before you make assumptions. Shame on you Target. GO TO WALMART!!!

Sounds logical to me. Someone gives a few bucks to the Salvation Army on the way into Target and that's a few bucks they don't have to spend inside the store where the rubber meets the road. Some guy with an MBA probably thought this one up. Smart business if you ask me.

I think the post by Dana V. is way off base. The "stupid" bell are rang by volunteers and people that the Army is assisting and are not "hired". Some times its hard to tell the difference between ignorant and stupid. Target is doing the right thing the right way.

I like the work the Salvation Army does and I contribute to their mailing once a year. I believe that Target should be able to set their own policies and should not be dictated by outside pressure. I would still shop at Target. I like to choose my Charities and I don't like to be pressured when shopping. Target does support the Salvation Army in their giving.

Target is a major contributor to many worthwhile causes, their employees volunteer, and they are high people with disabilities. The Salvation Army is everywhere else, so it's nice to get a break. I'm not connected in any way to Target, but have seen their good works.

Target has a LONG history of supporting local and national charities. They have plans where you can suport a school of your choice by usung their credit card. They have local organizations to work with homeless and latch key children. Just because a business allows the Bell Ringers in front of their door does not mean they are being "charitable", it just means thy would rather gain the positive press without doing anything themselves. If you want the Salvation Army or any organization to have money, send them a check youself.

I have volunteered with the Army for over 15 years on a year round basis. The stats show that the Army returns more of the funds received back to the community than any other charity. My father was a WWII vet who gave to no charity other than the Salvation Army. He was helped by the Army in England during the war when others would not help. He never forgot it. Let the bells ring.

I have not spent a dime at Target since they implemented this policy and try to convinse others not to also. The salvation Army is an American tradition at Christmas. If mean spirited people don't want to give a few coins they are not harrassed. It's Christmas time folks! don't be so mean. Gil

Since it is Target's corperate policy to not allow solicitation in front of its stores, then I think it does have to be applied across the board, without exceptions. They do make a million dollar donation to the Salvation Army and the sale of the special ornament will probably make up for whatever loss might be incurred by the lack of the bell ringers. I think Carrie's suggestion to shop at Walmart instead is crazy. Why would I want to shop at a store that has a reputation for treating it's employees like dirt, strong arming their suppliers, etc.? I will remain a loyal Target customer, regardless of whether the Salvation Army is allowed outside their doors, or not.

Back when I was bagging groceries, I would give a percentage of my tips everyday to the Salvation Army Person manning the kettle. However, since I have learned that they use their funds to support right wing political causes as well as helping the needy, I have stopped giving to them at all. I give my money to those who give 100% to the needy. I won't miss them in front of Target.

The Salvation Army is a great organization. This provides an easy opportunity for people who want to make a donation to do so. If you choose not to donate, it can just walk right into the store. Plus,it's very nostalgic to hear the bell ringing.

I totally agree with Target and appreciate for the way they care for customers' feeling. I don't want to be bothered everytime to go to shop during the holiday.

I have no problem shopping at Target WITHOUT the bell ringers. We were not put on this earth to be judged by the so called BELL RINGERS every year. Nor were we put on this earth to judge anyone else (Target) for their beliefs or policies. If Target does not allow ANY solicitations in front of their stores. Then they should not change the policy even for one certain charity no matter what the charity is. If I want to give to the charity I will. I dont feel the need to be hasseled everytime I enter a store this time of year. I understand the charity needs the support but the VOLUNTEERS they sometimes have do them more harm than good. We as a family will stand with Target on their decision.