Short-term concerns about the current "Santa Rally"
As the year draws to an end I thought it might be interesting to check in with Bernie Schaeffer, my boss, to get his thoughts on the short-term outlook. I asked him about his near-term outlook and he had three concerns about the action during the next few weeks.
The first concern is based on the level of optimistic comments being made by analysts. Tracking this form of "anecdotal sentiment" is time consuming as it requires constantly staying abreast of what is being discussed, but it offers a look into the mindset of the Street. When the expectations get one-sided, it can be warning sign to watch out for potential disappointments.
The second point of concern comes from the options market. Among other uses, options give investors a way to speculate and hedge. Monitoring the activity can give another perspective on what market players are feeling and expecting. The current data reveal a slant toward optimism as speculators have a preference for calls in some indices. Comparing the relative pricing of call options to put options also suggests optimism, as we have seen a contraction in the typical negative volatility skew we track.
His last point of concern is based on underlying deterioration in the small-cap area. The Russell 2000 Index (RUT) has turned lower after pushing to the 800 level, but most of the attention has been on the narrowly focused strength in blue-chip stocks.
Taken as a whole, it seems that expectations may have gotten a bit ahead of themselves, which opens up the possibility of some short-term volatility. However, Bernie is quick to point out that he is quite bullish about the overall outlook for next year. In BusinessWeek's poll of 80 strategists, Bernie maintains the highest year-end target for the Dow Jones Industrial Average. Calling for a new all-time high in the average, he does expect the economy will slow down next year, but believes that is already factored into expectations.
Nick Perry is an analyst with Schaeffer's Investment Research.
The first concern is based on the level of optimistic comments being made by analysts. Tracking this form of "anecdotal sentiment" is time consuming as it requires constantly staying abreast of what is being discussed, but it offers a look into the mindset of the Street. When the expectations get one-sided, it can be warning sign to watch out for potential disappointments.
The second point of concern comes from the options market. Among other uses, options give investors a way to speculate and hedge. Monitoring the activity can give another perspective on what market players are feeling and expecting. The current data reveal a slant toward optimism as speculators have a preference for calls in some indices. Comparing the relative pricing of call options to put options also suggests optimism, as we have seen a contraction in the typical negative volatility skew we track.
His last point of concern is based on underlying deterioration in the small-cap area. The Russell 2000 Index (RUT) has turned lower after pushing to the 800 level, but most of the attention has been on the narrowly focused strength in blue-chip stocks.
Taken as a whole, it seems that expectations may have gotten a bit ahead of themselves, which opens up the possibility of some short-term volatility. However, Bernie is quick to point out that he is quite bullish about the overall outlook for next year. In BusinessWeek's poll of 80 strategists, Bernie maintains the highest year-end target for the Dow Jones Industrial Average. Calling for a new all-time high in the average, he does expect the economy will slow down next year, but believes that is already factored into expectations.
Nick Perry is an analyst with Schaeffer's Investment Research.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
12-19-2006 @ 1:07PM
Jerry Bluhm said...
The slow down next year is being under reported in my opinion. I see the slow down to be more severe than most experts are reporting. Why? The housing market is soft and will get softer. The effect of the slow down in housing is just now beginning, and will be seen much more in the second half of 2007. Perhaps by the second quarter of 2007 the hard landing in the economy will be easier seen. Also, way to much optimism in the markets, based on what is happening in retail sales. Revenues may not be off too much in 4th quarter but profits I predict will.
1-02-2007 @ 2:25PM
Mike Pascale said...
I wish people reading this would read Bernie's "Monday Morning Outlook" column from the day before...he was BULLISH and noted as reasons the NEGATIVE sentiment: "While there are signs of optimism in the market (such as the high Investors Intelligence survey), there is a guarded quality to this optimism, as the financial media is filled with bearish comments and headlines regarding the low VIX and slowing economy."
I have always liked Mr. Schaeffer's web site (highly recommended) but hate it when he and other market "experts" talk out of both sides of their mouths.
You cannot have it both ways.No one respects politicians.