Others echo Overstock chief's cries of collusion
Quite a while ago, Overstock.com (NASDAQ: OSTK) CEO Patrick Byrne concluded that hedge fund managers were colluding with journalists and finance writers to manipulate stock prices of public companies. Byrne was vilified a bit for that stance, but now he's being vindicated a little with support from some surprising areas.
Both Jim Cramer and even reports from Bloomberg News state that there is indeed market manipulation going on to this day in commonplace fashion. I still can't get over why anyone would base an investing strategy (outside of day trading) on Cramer's Mad Money unless they are mesmerized by his showmanship, but I digress. The guy is smart, but there are plenty of other portfolios with better returns. Do your own research.
Anyway, Cramer's allegation that the financial press is easily duped by short sellers and hedge funds makes sense to me if you look at the daily activity levels and know precisely what to monitor to see patterns. Cramer also stated that federal regulators aren't smart enough to stop it -- another thing I agree with him on. The markets weren't set up for this kind of nonsense, but if there is short-term money to be made and the power of regulation is turtle-slow, you can bet people will be acclimating to it like bugs to a porch light.
Perhaps Byrne was right all along, as he did accuse a number of investment bankers, financial journalists and hedge fund managers of collaborating to ruin the reputations of companies in order to profit when their stock prices tumbled. It may be time for the federal henchmen to enter the picture and let Byrne finally bask in what he's wanted for quite some time.
Both Jim Cramer and even reports from Bloomberg News state that there is indeed market manipulation going on to this day in commonplace fashion. I still can't get over why anyone would base an investing strategy (outside of day trading) on Cramer's Mad Money unless they are mesmerized by his showmanship, but I digress. The guy is smart, but there are plenty of other portfolios with better returns. Do your own research.
Anyway, Cramer's allegation that the financial press is easily duped by short sellers and hedge funds makes sense to me if you look at the daily activity levels and know precisely what to monitor to see patterns. Cramer also stated that federal regulators aren't smart enough to stop it -- another thing I agree with him on. The markets weren't set up for this kind of nonsense, but if there is short-term money to be made and the power of regulation is turtle-slow, you can bet people will be acclimating to it like bugs to a porch light.
Perhaps Byrne was right all along, as he did accuse a number of investment bankers, financial journalists and hedge fund managers of collaborating to ruin the reputations of companies in order to profit when their stock prices tumbled. It may be time for the federal henchmen to enter the picture and let Byrne finally bask in what he's wanted for quite some time.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
3-31-2007 @ 3:52AM
Judd Bagley said...
Brian, this might be the single best blog post I've read in a year. But I'll take it one step further: the perpetrators of this manipulation don't stop with damaging the reputations of the companies they target...they invest heavily in damaging the reputations of these companies' leaders.
This, in my opinion, is what makes short and distort campaigns even more damaging and corrosive (despite being less common-place) than pump and dump schemes: the shorts make cowardly, libelous venom -- usually spewn anonymously or via complicit proxies -- a primary strategy.
Thank you for for your insight and spot-on commentary.
Judd Bagley
Writer of http://antisocialmedia.net
Director of Social Media at Overstock.com
Long-time Patrick Byrne loyalist
3-31-2007 @ 8:30AM
Brian White said...
Thanks Judd for your comments. I was vividly interested in Patrick's comments a back in '05, and it's rather comforting to see Cramer literally back him up recently with his "shorters manipulate the market" bombshell. Might as well drag company leaders through the mud (along with stock price) as to be able and make short profits in utterly ludicrous fashion. It is complete nonsense, and at least Mr. Byrne had the guts to call out the situation way ahead of everyone else.
Regards,
Brian
4-08-2007 @ 6:25PM
Sam E. Antar (former Crazy Eddie CFO & ex-felon) said...
To Judd Bagley (Director of Social Media at Overstock.com)
You wrote:
“…the shorts make cowardly, libelous venom -- usually spewn anonymously or via complicit proxies -- a primary strategy.”
Question:
Are you using the same tactics against critics of Patrick Byrne and you?
Respectfully,
Sam E. Antar (former Crazy Eddie CFO & convicted felon)
PS:
My blog post:
Don’t Mess with Overstock.com CEO Patrick Byrne
Link here:
http://whitecollarfraud.blogspot.com/2007/04/dont-mess-with-overstockcom-ceo-patrick.html