American Idol didn't just jump the shark last night. It transformed itself into a nauseating celebration of corporate sponsorship and celebrity self-indulgence that was breathtaking to behold.
Though AIDS in Africa and hunger in America are serious issues that deserve the public's attention and charitable donations, I had trouble taking "Idol Gives Back" seriously. Then again, my cynicism kicks into high gear whenever I see a gaggle of celebrities trying hard to convince me that I should care about something. Actors and corporations have a right under the first amendment to express their political views, but I have just as much of a right to ignore them.
"Idol Gives Back" was all about the close bonds between Hollywood and Wall Street.
American Idol makes big money from the advertising that's integrated into its show such as the glasses on the judges' table that have the Coca-Cola Co. (NYSE: KO) logo on them and those idiotic Ford Motor Co. (NYSE: F) commercials featuring the contestants doing renditions of pop hits that have as much musicality as a high school rendition of "Grease."
As an Idol viewer, I can live with all of that stuff. Heck, I even put up with the hapless Sanjaya Malakar, who was in the audience last night.
But host Ryan Seacrest took America's top-rated program into new territory last night with his prodigious thanking of all of the sponsors, including Fox's parent News Corp. (NYSE: NWS) and ExxonMobil Corp. (NYSE: XOM). He made these multi-billion corporations sound almost saintly at times.
There were some highlights from the show that I won't soon forget, try as I might, such as Academy Award-winning actress Helen Mirren lip-synching to the Bee Gees disco classic "Stayin' Alive." Jack Black got the night's biggest laugh when he did an over-the-top rendition of an over-the-top ballad by Seal "A Kiss from a Rose," who just happened to be sitting in the front row of the audience. Of course, Seal said he liked Black's performance.
In case you were wondering what comedy writers are doing in Hollywood now that fewer sitcoms are being produced, now you have your answer.
But I would have put up with all of that too if American Idol lived up to its promise and told the audience which wannabe pop star was being sent home. Unfortunately, the show's producers decided that it would be too much of a downer for the audience who watched a two hours' worth of videos of death and despair.
I know that two Idols are going to get sacked next week, but I don't know if I'll be watching. There's only so much heartache that a TV viewer can take. Besides, it's baseball season. If I have a choice between being played and watching people play, I'll take the latter.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-26-2007 @ 3:31PM
Eric said...
The Biggest Shock of Idol was the Look on Jordin Sparks Face and that of her family when Seacreast said Chris Richardson you are safe. The dramtic pause to let Jordin know she wouldn't be elimanted from AI also, was just cruel.
http://idol-mania.com/american-idol-fan
4-26-2007 @ 3:35PM
Connie said...
I thought AI was good last night. Yeah it was a downer watching whats going on in other parts of the world and in parts of the US! I think it made alot of people realize that maybe they don't have it so bad after all. But,I would like to know how they got Elvis on stage!
4-26-2007 @ 4:51PM
dn1234 said...
WAHHHHHHH...would you like some cheese with your WHINE?
4-26-2007 @ 8:24PM
nate smith said...
Wow, those self indulgent a-holes raised 60 million dollars to fight poverty. What a bunch of pricks, right?
4-29-2007 @ 8:55PM
Holley Robison said...
I think everyone should be ashamed if you thought American Idol sucked this week cause it didn't wa so what if someone didn't get voted off, It was soppuse to be about Gving back to people that are in need, but a lot of people are just to stuck up to think that and all they want to see is who is the next person they can falsely worship. Idol sucks in my opinon the only thing good that ever came out of it is Kelly Clarkson, she on her third CD while everyone else sort of fades into the bacground, but I have a lot more respect for American Idol after they decided they wanted to address some major problems that everyone should be worried about.
5-23-2007 @ 7:38PM
Nadine Butler said...
I don't agree with you about no one but Kelly Clarkston is the only American Idol that amounted to somthing. Do you remember a former contestamt getting an Academy Award?