Motorola CEO doesn't want Icahn

In spite of its lackluster performance of late, Motorola (NYSE: MOT) has decided it doesn't want King Icahn [subscription required]. CEO Ed Zander wrote letters to shareholders and employees saying Icahn is "not the right person to serve as a Motorola director." More puzzlingly, Zander wrote that Icahn's responsibility to his hedge fund investors "may conflict with his ability to represent all stockholders."

Now hold on. Icahn's responsibility to his hedge fund investors is to generate high returns. The board's responsibility to shareholders is to generate high returns. So what's the conflict? Given Icahn's ownership of 3% of MOT stock -- an investment worth over a billion dollars -- it's hard to imagine someone whose interests are better-aligned with those of outside shareholders.

Mr. Zander, it's beyond me why you wouldn't welcome one of the foremost business and governance experts of our time on the company's board. This looks like it has more to do with Zander's desire to keep control over the company than any altruistic desire to "represent all stockholders."