The Motley Fool's Dan Caplinger takes a look at the issue of credit piggybacking, and what the industry is looking to do about it. Basically, someone with a low credit score can pay someone with a better score to add them to their accounts as an authorized user, without actually using the account. There are companies that offer this "service" and, needless to say, the credit card companies aren't happy about it because it distorts credit. It allows completely irresponsible people to buy good FICO scores. It's no different than buying SAT scores from someone else to get into a good college.
While it's hard to have too much sympathy for the credit card companies, they have a right to be upset here. Fair Isaac (NYSE: FIC) has simply elected to stop considering authorized users when calculating credit scores, which seems like a logical step.
A crackdown on piggybacking could also lead to the demise of one of the easiest ways for parents to build credit histories for their children: adding them as authorized users. I'd like to see this end as well because the principle is the same. People should not get credit for stuff they had nothing to do with. It also reeks of nepotism, and seems unfair to kids whose parents don't have good credit. Do we really need to give rich kids another advantage? By piggybacking off their parents credit, kids with responsible parents can have great credit scores without ever having a credit card. Kids with less fortunate parents don't have that opportunity, and that's wrong.
There's no intelligent reason that piggybacking on credit should be allowed, and it will probably be stopped soon.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
6-07-2007 @ 7:07AM
hal c said...
As it stands now if the primary user has a high balance on their card the authorised user suffers a lower credit score.
Fair Isaac (what an ironic name) doesn't seem too concerned about that. For years the credit reporting agencies have thumbed their noses at the general public. Only when Congress acted did they even allow us to see our credit scores without paying a fee.
Hell, they ought to have to pay us for the privlidge of using our names to make money.
6-07-2007 @ 3:28PM
Emily said...
Did you see the latest FICO announcement about piggybacking? They've decided to change their formula (which they never do) to no longer take into account authorized user tradelines.
This should stop the credit repair loophole, but at the same time about 30% of the population could see their credit score decrease significantly.
Former FICO insider, John Ulzheimer, has more information about the change online here - http://www.creditbloggers.com/2007/06/what_does_the_f.html