My distinguished colleague Sheldon Liber wrote a post about Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL) and in it he claims that Jim Cramer is recommending investors take some profits. Cramer's feeling is that Apple is trading into the iPhone release on June 29th and the stock may trade off after iPhone hoopla is over. There are others stating that there may be some "fluff" in the price of Apple. Get real, folks -- time to learn about growth investing as opposed to "value" investing.
In fairness I should disclose that I have been recommending Apple since it was under $20 per share back in 2004. Institutional clients of mine have heard me sing the praises of what Apple was undertaking since then. My web site was founded in late September 2006 and I recommended Apple from day one. The stock was just above $70. So, it would be easy for me to advise now to capture a $55 profit in these short 8-9 months since I recommended the stock. Right? Wrong.
Apple is a bona fide super growth story on many levels and is not overpriced. The fiscal year ends for Apple on September 30, 2007 and I estimate it will report total revenues of $24 billion and earnings per share of $3.55, which by the way, I have raised the estimates for the year after Apple's quarterly reports the last 4 quarters. I estimate for September 30, 2008 fiscal year Apple can generate revenues of $29.5-30 billion and earnings per share of $4.05-4.10 -- again estimates raised several times.
Yes, the stock has jumped around in its climb to $124. It had some down days, heck, down weeks ... but the fundamentals have not changed -- they actually have improved over this past year. The fundamentals have strengthened because of the iPod market penetration and market share gains: all in a growth market. The Mac has been revamped and also gaining market share along with attendant software sales. The iPhone is out June 29th and frankly my estimates call for a modest contribution for the September quarter, but more meaningful for fiscal 2008. Remember, Apple will recognize the revenues from iPhone over the 24 month initial contract commitment.
What iPhone does and many professional portfolio managers "get it" , is set up Apple for continued mega growth for the 2008-2011 period. It's going to be a 3-4 year phenom. These portfolio managers are not buying Apple for value -- it's a pure growth story. Period. It's a game changer, the leader along with Google (NASDAQ: GOOG) in the technology sector.
If you want a technology "value" name, look at Cisco (NASDAQ: CSCO) or Oracle (NASDAQ: ORCL) or even IBM (NYSE: IBM). They have all stumbled, smoothed out their respective businesses and are embarking on modest growth. But king of the mountains they are no longer.
The supposed geniuses were skeptical on Apple after the last 5-6 quarterly reports. "Oh, the stock is a sell here at $60. Too expensive". "Okay, now I am serious, it's a sell at $80-85 -- too expensive again". Then Apple hit the magical barrier of $100! " Now, it's really a sell. No way they can sustain, right?" Wrong again.
Folks, growth investing focuses on the simple metrics of revenue growth, earnings growth, market share position and/or gains, gross margins and operating margins elasticity, domestic and global addressable market size, product cycles and new releases, distribution methodology and the most important: the quality of senior management. Apple scores very high in all these areas.
So, can the stock rise to $160? Yes, absolutely. Professional portfolio managers are looking at fiscal 2008 earnings of $4.05, but are also understanding the clear pathway to $5.00-5.20 for Fiscal year 2009. Can the stock trade back down to $110? Sure, markets are never linear. But I believe Apple will see $160 some time over the next 12 months if not more. So why would I sell here and "hope" it falls back to $110? What if it doesn't trade down because the June quarter numbers are excellent with even better visibility for the September quarter?
If you want to trade around the fringes, my colleague Sheldon Liber makes a great point about factoring in capital gains taxes and transaction costs. I have been asked the question many times since $20: should I take some off the table? My answer is, do the math. The stock still has quite a way to go.
Georges Yared is the CIO of Yared Investment Research.
Why Facebook's Falling Share Price Really Doesn't Matter
Mark Zuckerberg and Priscilla Chan: A Romantic Facebook Timeline


Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
6-11-2007 @ 11:13AM
Sheldon L said...
Nice post Georges. Just a few things...
A drop of $15, or 12% does qualify as "a little fluff". We are in agreement that it would be foolish to jump in and out for that level of price variation. The only reason to sell is to diversify; timing the market as Cramer likes to do often leads to disaster.
6-11-2007 @ 11:28AM
Bobby Dee said...
Your estimates give Apple a P/E of 35 and an expected growth rate from '07 to '08 of 14%. Even your '09 guesstimates put the P/E in the mid-20s. I'm not clear how that's a really compelling story, especially as we all know that a lot can happen in two years.
6-13-2007 @ 4:51PM
Chuck said...
Can someone tell me a little bit about how the stocks have been treating everyone. i am interested in investing and would like some information about th company. I would also like a brief run down about what is coming up in the future and how that will help the stocks.
6-11-2007 @ 6:23PM
dave e said...
Hello all,
More of a tech question about apple, and specifically the IPhone.
If one purchases the IPHONE, will it be possible to just use the IPod and wireless internet connect portions, without a subscription to ATT phone service ?
thanks, dave