Pennsylvania-based energy company Allegheny Energy, Inc. (NYSE: AYE) posted mixed results for 1Q 2007 earnings. On the positive side, retail sales of energy increased 5%, plant efficiency increased, operating revenues increased $2 million, and debt expense declined by $8.2 million.. On the negative side, coal costs were up by $13.5 million, wiping out all the gains in increased sales and plant efficiency. Retail market prices for energy were down further eroding the gain produced by increased sales volume. Net income for the quarter was down by $4.5 million to $109.7 million or $.65 EPS. EBITDA for 1Q 2007 was $312.6 million, a decrease of $9.5 million.

Now for the bad news. The West Virginia Public Service Commission just recently ordered Allegheny Energy to decrease rates by $132 million to 2 Allegheny Enengy subsidiaries, while allowing Allegheny Enegy to pass on a $126 million fuel charge to customers. Net loss to Allegheny Energy is an additional $6 million. This is, relatively speaking, not that big a deal for Allegheny Energy, which posts annual revenues in excess of $3 billion. But the company did get slapped around in public for being heavy-handed in trying to push more costs than allowed onto customers. Its long term growth prospects are not rosy. There is growing opposition to its new power line project in its transmission area in West Virginia, Pennsylavia and Maryland. It's P/E multiple, 27.63, is the highest among its competitors while its EPS, $1.87, is the lowest. Allegheny Energy suspended dividend payments in December 2002 and has yet to reinstitute them. None of its cost factors are going to change for the better in the immediate future. It is best to look elsewhere for utility stock investment possibilities. The stock recently closed at $51.81, down $1.10.