Moody's late to the private equity bashing party

Zac Bissonnette posted earlier how Moody's Corp. (NYSE: MCO) criticized private equity. What strikes me is just how late Moody's is to join the critical chorus.

Roughly 11 months ago I made arguments similar to the ones that Moody's is making today. And I was pleased that some media outlets -- specifically Barron's Alan Abelson -- picked up on them. What really got me going is that as of August 2006, there were two busted IPOs from which Bain Capital -- as the Boston Globe reports enriched presidential candidate Mitt Romney -- took enormous fees:

• Vonage Holdings Corp. (NYSE: VG) - Bain Capital and others lent Vonage $200 million before taking this money-loser public. VG has lost 80% of its value since the May 2006 IPO.
• Burger King Holdings, Inc. (NYSE: BKC) - That same month, Bain Capital and others took a $30 million "management termination fee" out of Burger King before taking it public. (This fee is chump change compared to the $367 million dividend Bain Capital and its partners extracted from Burger King in February 2006.) By August 2006, Burger King had tumbled 26% since its IPO after announcing that it lost $9 million in its fiscal fourth quarter due, in part, to the management termination fee. Fortunately for its shareholders, the stock has doubled since then.

It takes a long time for a battleship the size of private equity to turn. But when Moody's -- which is supposed to be protecting the public from poorly structured debt rather than profiting from it -- kills its formerly golden goose, the time for turning may be closer than it was a year ago.

Peter Cohan is president of Peter S. Cohan & Associates, a management consulting and venture capital firm. He also teaches management at Babson College and edits The Cohan Letter. He has no financial interest in the securities mentioned in this post.