This post is part of our Money Face-Offs feature. Let us know who you think comes out ahead in this head-to-head match-up, and check out our other Money Face-Off posts.
The technology stories of the 1980s have a lot to do with the dawn of the PC era. IBM was about to license its personal computer technology to the open market (leading to the rising popularity of Microsoft) and Apple's computers were a hit-or-miss proposition with consumers as el-cheapo PCs made their entrance and became the dominant force in many homes and offices. Remember 1,200-bps modems and bulletin boards, folks?
Microsoft's arguably illegal tactics made it flourish in the 1990s under CEO and company cofounder William H. Gates, and the debate continues to this day whether the Windows 3.0 and Windows 95 operating systems were in part copies of Apple's MacIntosh operating system. Suggested viewing: Pirates of Silicon Valley.
Apple seemed dead in the water in the mid '90s, and Microsoft was growing by leaps and bounds. Bill Gates became the richest person in the world on paper (which would last more than a decade), and Steve Jobs came back in 1997 to try and resurrect a floundering Apple that had not done much in terms of innovation or growth under then-CEO Gil Amelio. Gates seemed on top of the world; Jobs, not so much.
My how times change. Last year, Gates said he would step down from Microsoft Inc. (NASDAQ: MSFT) to focus on his philanthropy, and Steve Jobs has accomplished the impossible -- he's made Apple Inc. (NASDAQ: AAPL) a contender in the PC space again. Apple has done no wrong since about 2002 when the iPod created a new culture and a new stock price movement for Apple. The rest is history. Sure, Microsoft launched Windows Vista in early 2007, which was Gates's curtain call at the company he cofounded. It was launched at the wrong time, all things considered (PC makers probably wanted something new to trumpet), and Apple's iPod was just killing the competition, including Microsoft's Zune.
From 1997, Microsoft and Apple -- in a way -- changed places. Microsoft's reign under Bill Gates created many millionaires and the company continues to grow very nicely to this day. Steve Jobs has invented Apple again under the guise of music players in an attempt to grow PC sales in a halo effect; he's also made Apple one of the coolest brands on the planet at the same time. If you were to take the return from owning Microsoft stock from 1997 to 2007 or Apple's stock, which would have made you richer? Exactly 10 years ago, AAPL shares were trading at $5.55 each, and MSFT shares stood at $17.16. Do a little homework to adjust for splits and the like, and would being stock buddies with Jobs or Gates land you in a better position? Vote now.
Vote in our poll for Bill Gates or Steve Jobs, and let us know in the comments why your choice has the financial edge in this match-up. Also be sure to check out our other Money Face-Offs.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
9-15-2007 @ 3:16PM
tom B said...
Gee, on the one side you have a guy that makes fun, useful, beautiful, products that actually WORK; on the other side, you have a guy that uses threats and monopoly tcatics to sell awful products that are almost universally despised. Tough choice.
9-15-2007 @ 8:42PM
Moctod said...
[IBM was about to license its personal computer technology to the open market]
Perhaps you meant Compaq was about to reverse engineer IBM's portion of their personal computer technology — the ROM BIOS — and release it to the open market. Along with the freely available MS-DOS.
[Microsoft's arguably illegal tactics made it flourish in the 1990s under CEO and company cofounder William H. Gates]
Convicted TWICE for being an illegal monopoly is hardly — 'arguably illegal'.
9-16-2007 @ 4:44AM
Beltway Greg said...
Judging by the size of the crowds at the Apple stores this weekend I sure as hell know which one is going to make me richer next week. Prediction: .25 rate cut on Tuesday. Will stocks explode? Probably get a bounce on Monday and a mild move on Tuesday and then once everyone figures out that the rate cut isn't wearing a beard and sandals and can't save GS and the like we might even have a down week next week because we had a very good week this week.
Beltway Greg.
"Buying on the margin is like not even buying at all."
9-17-2007 @ 8:14AM
Nehemi Vincent said...
to tell the most truth i love microsoft better but apple inc. is specialized in making these unbelievable products that are kindof impossible to buy and complicated.
9-18-2007 @ 5:56AM
jain said...
Bill Gates is already in heaven having Net Worth of 56 billion dollars.Thats huge money.
9-18-2007 @ 11:13PM
SwitchBlog said...
MacIntosh? Ahem.