Mutual funds cry foul over new ETF product

Posted Feb 19th 2008 4:35PM by Zack Miller
Filed under: International Markets, Products and Services, Indices, Commodities

When the entire mutual fund industry is up in arms about a new form of ETF, should investors take note? You bet they should.

There's an interesting article over on SeekingAlpha by HardAssetsInvestor. The article focuses on the Exchange Traded Note product, something I've written about previously. The ETN is similar to an ETF in that it's a fund that trades like a stock. Unlike ETFs though, the ETN is not backed by the underlying assets. Rather, it's a zero-coupon note (essentially, a bond) that's backed by its underwriters. So, it throws an added layer of default risk into the whole investment game.

Where things get even more interesting is the tax treatment of the ETN product. Says HardAssetInvestor's Brad Zigler, "No tax consequence befalls the noteholder until the security is liquidated or matures. Taxes during the holding period? Zip. Nada. Bupkis. That beats the heck out of the tax treatment of mutual funds, too, which distribute income and capital gains." Unlike ETFs investing in commodities which are treated with a complicated tax structure on the futures the funds invest in, ETNs don't pass these taxes through to investors.

It's this tax difference that has the big mutual fund industry up in arms. According to the article cited above, "The Investment Company Institute [ICI], an industry trade group, called on Congress and the Internal Revenue Service to step in and mitigate the "unwarranted, unintended and unfair" tax advantage enjoyed by ETNs."

Things are going to get interesting and at the least, investors in commodity ETNs like DJP, RJI or GSP can benefit from the sparring match between ETN firms and the large mutual funds families.

Zack Miller is the managing editor of IsraelNewsletter.com and a former equity analyst for a leading multinational hedge fund.

Tags: djp, etf, etn, gsp, inthenews, mutual fund, MutualFund, rji

Print this

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)

2-22-2008 @ 3:02AM

Leela said...

Please mention portfolio Managers are the funds

2-22-2008 @ 3:02AM

Leela said...

Please mention Portfolio managers of the funds

5-08-2008 @ 5:56AM

Brian Boor. said...

WDear sir,
ith due respect, we want to introduce www.yesuncle.com as one of the leading online e-mail marketing advertisers of many reputed portals of all kinds. We have strength of thousands of potential costmers for whom success our team works day'n'night. Although they are big corporates or one man organisation. As you know how fast internet industry is growing & many many new tribes/people are joining this day by day & it is becoming the need of all of them. Now this is our intelligency & smartness how we extract better & more effective results from this boom.
If you think this e-mail marketing stratgy is economical as compare to other ways of marketing & is suitable for success of your portal. Than visit our website www.yesuncle.com .
Hope and pray for your success.
With regards
Brian Boor.