This post is part of our Battle of the Brands feature. Let us know which brand you prefer, and check out other Battle of the Brands posts.
When it comes to comparing the pick-up trucks of Ford Motor Co. (NYSE: F) and Chevrolet by General Motors Corp. (NYSE: GM), I can honestly say that I've owned both brands. I bought one F-150 off the showroom floor. I also bought one that was very well used. Both my Chevy Silverados were low-mileage, used models. I leased one of them from my dad and the other one I bought from my brother. I have also had opportunities to drive multiple specimens of each brand that were owned by friends or associates. I like both brands as far as their trucks go. Their cars are a story for another day.
To me, Chevy trucks always seem a bit more solid, with interior appointments a little more lush and inviting. Ford trucks seem to focus more on utility and usability within a bit roomier interior. The Chevy trucks always exhibit deep power, easily delivered upon demand. Fords trucks always seem a bit more spunky with their aggressiveness always close under foot. Chevy trucks appeal to the gentleman in me but they've always done any job I asked of them. Ford trucks appeal to the workman in me and they sometimes seem immortal.
Chevy pick-up trucks are always quieter than the Fords. Ford pick-up trucks always seem a bit more nimble than the Chevys. I expect both brands to work hard, and work hard they do. I'd take either brand any day for any job I need done. There are other brands which I've owned or would like to get my hands on, but today's battle is between these two mighty classics. I dearly hope that I can afford to keep buying gas for the one that's sitting on my driveway!
Vote in our poll for Chevy or Ford as your preferred brand, and let us know in the comments why you love it.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 5)
4-28-2008 @ 8:16PM
Cindi said...
I have to say I prefer Chevy over Ford any day. I am 48 years old and have owed one of each in my lifetime. Chevy always got me where and when i wanted to go somewhere and has never broke down on me ,like ford has. And it seems to me chevy auotmobile plants who make em' has more pride in the vehicles they make. Now the only vehicle i own is a chevy still after all these years. Keep on making the best product out the Chevrolet!
Cindi,Flint
4-28-2008 @ 8:29PM
Larry McDaniel said...
Have owned both, and I always drive them as long as possible. I am driving my second Chevy truck, in a row. I have gotten over twice the life out of the
vortec engines that I ever did with any of my Ford trucks. Guess you would say I am sold on the vortec engine !
4-28-2008 @ 8:32PM
rick said...
I've pulled too many chevies home and out of holes with my fords
4-28-2008 @ 8:32PM
Barrie said...
I've driven Ford trucks over 950,000 miles over 35 years and they have never let me down. The current truck is a F-250 diesel @ 205,000 miles that still delivers 17 MPG even loaded to 8000 lbs. all the time. That said I think the Chevy is probably just as good...............It just depends on which one you are more comfortable with.
4-28-2008 @ 8:33PM
Bob Gillespie said...
I have owned or leased three Ford F-150's over the past 13 years and have found them to be rugged, reliable, comfortable, powerful and beautiful. Most people don't know that only Ford has a tubular frame. The others have frames that have one or two open sides and are, therefore) not nearly as strong. This is never apparent on the showroom floor because most buyers don't crawl underneath to look. Of course, as far a looks go, one man's meat is another man's poison.
Having said that, I prefer Ford's rounded curves (interior and exterior) to Silverado's boxier, hard lines.
4-28-2008 @ 8:34PM
Cece Hite said...
I am not sure what year truck that Gary tested but the Ford truck is much more solid than the Chevy truck. Gary should watch the truth about trucks and he could see the difference in how the two trucks are built! Park the two trucks on a slant on a hill and see which one has the bed still straight with the cab. It is not the Chevy!
When it comes to safety look at the wrap around the engine frame on the Ford versus the no frame around the engine at all in the Chevy. I have seen a Chevy truck T- bone a Ford Ranger and the Chevy 2500 got the worst of the bargain with the Chevy front end sitting in the drivers lap and the Ranger just banged up and the Ranger is a small truck!
As far as interiors the Ford has more interiors than the Chevy and if you see the Limited, King Ranch, Lariat or Harley Davidson you have lots of choices.
4-28-2008 @ 8:50PM
rambo said...
I MUST TELL ONE AND ALL, THE FORD IS THE BEST BUILD TRUCK YET. IT MIGHT NOT RIDE LIKE A BOAT, BUT YOU CAN GET THINGS DONE WITH IT. CHEVY MIGHT RIDE SMOOTHER, BUT THAT'S FOR THE CITY SLICKER. BESIDES, I DON'T LIKE THE LOOKS OF THE CHEVY. IT DOESN'T EVEN LOOK LIKE A WORK TRUCK. GO FORD-----
4-28-2008 @ 8:56PM
Dan said...
I've owned both Chevy and Ford, and as far as Ford goes, They don't make them like they used to. I owned (2) 71's, and a 72 Ford P/U. The 71's had a 302, and the other a 360. The 302 lacked the power I wanted and the 360 had so many miles, I couldn't tell the difference between the two. I did have a 390 in the 72 and even though it's from the same block as the 360, (called FE), I liked it so much I completly rebuilt it, and put that truck through some extreme punishment, and it didn't fail me once. One winter it was so cold,(wind chill -50 degrees), my 72 Ford P/U was the only vehicle in the apt. complex that started and even though I was Out of work due to the cold, that truck made up my lost wages giving people jump starts and offering rides to neighbors that had to get to work. I even got an ultimatum from my EX- Wife,her or the truck, she hated it. I guess I should have kept the truck- hence-EX in WIFE.
The Chevrolet side of the coin, I had a few 1/2 ton trucks in my time. Mostly late 80's models. Great reliable trucks once I got rid of the throtle body carbs, and the fuel switch between the two tanks,
(plumbed them together). Loved the rumble from the duel exhaust and the nice Cackel from a mild camshaft up grade.
Alltogether, I seem to favor the Chevy's over the Fords because of the economical value of replacement parts were a lot cheeper than that of the Fords. Once the 390 Ford was rebuilt, I would challenge (and did) a SS454 Chevy and quite easily enbarrased the driver of that pretty black SS454. That 390-3-on-the-tree made it look simple once I hit second gear. Guess he should've opted for the small-block.
4-28-2008 @ 9:07PM
RB said...
Can't beat the ride and quiet of the Chevys.
Also, the GM Allison transmission is streets ahead of Ford in reliability.
When someone brags about their Ford transmission, it's always: "I know 5 guys that had to replace their Allisons".
- I've never met one of those "5 guys" yet.
The arguement will be moot as Toyota trucks get more popular, and Ford goes bankrupt.
All our Fords have been troublesome, and the dealers the worst to work with.
4-28-2008 @ 9:09PM
Darren said...
Any domestic truck is pretty good but I love my Dodge's. The power and styling in unmatched by ford or chevy. My Hemi has more than enough power for any job and the truck itself looks great.
4-28-2008 @ 9:10PM
Ron said...
I have driven Fords for years but I also had Chevys for many years before that. I love the Fords but I always buy used and would not hesitate to buy another Chevy for the right price. I consider both to be excellent trucks. Just don't try to even give me a Dodge.
4-28-2008 @ 9:25PM
ChevyPoder said...
I've been buying chevy trucks and cars since 1965. In my family it is a tradition. I have 4 kids and they all have chevy trucks. My truck is a 1995 and it has a little over 250,000 miles and still purrs. I get 30, yes 30 miles per gallon. The only time I ever drove a Ford truck it broke down on me and left me stranded and that was when cell phones were scarce in my family so since that happened I never trusted Ford. The last chevy I had was a 1980 dual tank and I gave that one to my son-in-law who is now sold on Chevys too. Try One You'll Like It.
4-28-2008 @ 9:25PM
Robert said...
FORD ALL THE WAY!!!!
4-28-2008 @ 9:26PM
D Fritts said...
thousands of NBHA barrel racers can't be wrong! When it comes to pullin' those big living quarters/horse trailers, the Big Fords win !!!!
4-28-2008 @ 9:31PM
CBar said...
I bought a new 2005 F350 Ford Powerstroke, it almost bankrupted me. I broke down 9 times in 8 months. Ford denied warranty even though the problems started at 57,000 miles. Chevrolet had a problem and extended coverage to 200,000 miles. No more Fords for me pickups or otherwise.
4-28-2008 @ 9:34PM
Grammy said...
I have driven a FORD for over 40 years and I wouldn't own anything else. My F150 crew thinks it's a car, but works like a truck. Love it!
4-28-2008 @ 9:35PM
DIANE said...
I have a 1997 F-150 4x4.Bought it used in 2005.It was a one owner vehicle with 85,000 miles on it.Very immaculate condition. I now have 133,000
miles on it.It still looks awsome and like new.I have put new shocks,radiator,tires,emission sensors.It runs like a dream.I am now going to buy a F-250 and still keeping my 150.They don't call them"FORD TOUGH FOR NOTHING".....
FORD-WOMAN ALL THE WAY
4-28-2008 @ 9:57PM
LJ said...
I had a 94 Silverado which was an excellent truck. It was a 3/4 ton that often hauled 1 1/2 tons. About the only thing i can recall replacing was the water pump at about 180,000 miles. I sold it (mistake) in 2005 with 204,000 miles and it barely had any rust, near new interior, and still ran quiet. I have a 2007 which is nice, but can't say it's as good as the 94. I like the chevy lines and dislike the ford the most of all trucks--hated that homely melted look. Actually, right now i would say the GMC is the best looking truck on the market. I also have heard the horror stories about the new fords and their service problems (seems to be on their larger/heavier models).
4-28-2008 @ 10:03PM
Sandi said...
I have owned several Fords in the past and they were ALL lemons. I have had 2 Chevy Suburban's that I never had any problems with and now have a Chevy 3500 Dually that I use for Towing my horse trailer. I Love it!
One thing I noticed when shopping for my truck. I had a difficult time finding Used CHEVY/GMC's. However, I noticed that the dealerships and internet sites were flooded with Dodges and Fords. What does this tell you??? People who own Chevy's, KEEP THEM! I'm sold on Chevy Trucks!!
4-28-2008 @ 10:13PM
LK said...
Check out the fact that a Chevy truck can accidentally be put into gear in the accessory key position. You do not have to apply brake to shift out of park while in accessory. The "brake-shift interlock system" is only effective while the vehicle is running. If you are working around your truck and only have radio playing you can accidently hit shifter or a child can pull and vehicle is put into motion. People have been seriously hurt or killed from this. Almost all other vehicle models require applying brake to shift gears in any key position. (As a side note the GMC Yukon basically same as Chevy Suburban does have this safety feature). Beware of what could happen. Choose the safer FORD