Many people are saying that the rise in oil prices is the result of loose monetary policy. They say that there is an easy solution to the problem. Raise interest rates substantially, and the problem will be solved. Since the rise in oil is also the primary cause of rising inflation, the inflation problem will be resolved as well.
There are several problems with this line of reasoning. Oil continued to rise as the Fed began to increase interest rates in 2004. Prices doubled as the Fed substantially tightened monetary policy. Europe also has the some of the same inflation issues that we face despite the refusal of the European Central Bank (ECB) to lower rates.
Then, there are the big questions. Why are oil prices rising? What is the short-term solution?
I believe that the main reason for the rise in oil prices is the rise of the developing world. The two nine hundred pound gorillas in this equation are India and China. Automobile demand is increasing in these countries and is likely to continue in the near future.
This is similar to the rise in oil prices in the late 1960's and early 1970's. After World War II, the United States was the primary industrial power. As the world industrialized, demand for oil increased. The United States was not the only nation driving cars extensively. Supply constraints were also introduced in the mid to late 1970's with the Arab oil embargo and the Iranian revolution.
Is there a short-term solution for the problem? Eventually, the situation reaches a "tipping point." Demand decreases because of substitution for other forms of energy, and alternative supplies are developed. When will this occur? No one is really certain.
During the time period prior to this tipping point, inflation from rising oil occurs. The Fed could conceivably raise interest rates substantially enough to cause a severe global recession. The decrease in demand could temporarily lower oil prices. However, the cure may actually be worse than the disease. In addition, as the world economy recovered, oil prices would begin to rise again.
Therefore, the Fed is forced to tolerate inflation until this tipping point is reached. It hopes to be able to prevent these inflationary expectations from becoming embedded in the system.
This is further complicated by current housing decline and the credit crisis. If the Fed adopts a monetary policy that is too tight, it could cause a severe recession.
Thus, the current environment of real interest rates (interest rates adjusted for inflation) being negative may continue for some time. This favors small-cap stocks. An extended negative real interest rate environment indicates some type of a small-cap rally. As we saw at the beginning of this decade, small caps' performance advantage over large-cap stocks as represented by the S&P 500 can be quite substantial.
Doug Roberts is the Founder and Chief Investment Strategist for ChannelCapitalResearch.com, and is the author of Follow the Fed® to Investment Success: The Effortless Strategy for Beating Wall Street. He previously held executive positions at Morgan Stanley Group and Sanford C. Bernstein & Co.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
5-09-2008 @ 10:37AM
john said...
All speculation, speculators driving of the price, Bush in bed with oil companies, this problem should be solved. Bush out of office equals lower prices
5-09-2008 @ 10:47AM
Jeff said...
There is no short term solution. That is the whole reason we are in this mess, people only looking at the short term.
5-09-2008 @ 10:58AM
Rev.Jack said...
Price gouching is Illegal,except when, it puts money in your pocket... This is the Republican Flagship... We should outlaw,PUMP RAPE..
300% profit, without raising the rest of the market items, including wages, is PUMP RAPE... Raise my wages 300%, and I'll be glad to pay your 300% profit at the PUMP....! Do the math AMERICA, send this Email to your Lawmakers...
5-09-2008 @ 10:57PM
The Baron said...
There is a short term solution,but our political representatives and those seeking the office of
president,Republicans and Democrats have the guts to even suggest it. It is called rationing. And it can be structured to reduce waste and excessive misuse of petoleum products without hurting the
economy. They did it in WW2 and it can be done now. This will not only bring crude prices down 50%,but it will strengthen the dollar and reduce inflation dramatically. And,you can bet,alternative
fuels and energy sources will come to market "tout suite."
5-10-2008 @ 12:54PM
willard hashimoto said...
What, me worry? Save .34 cents per gallon on gasoline. Visit WWW.4ourFuture.com/FreeEnergy