Welcome to the 61st installment of The Wal-Mart Weekly, a column dedicated to bringing you insight, wit, facts, results, opinions, and just a bit of everything else when it comes to a very hot topic these days: Wal-Mart.
After examining two big sets of related shareholder resolutions for Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.'s (NYSE: WMT) annual shareholder meeting coming up in June in the past few weeks, we'll depart this week from that path.
I'll be examining one of Wal-Mart's newest websites, what it means and what (on earth) it'll have in terms of an impact on Wal-Mart customers. And, I'll ask one large question: why doesn't the world's largest retailer use its stores as a freely available advertising venue to let its customers know what it has available online? Let's examine, shall we?
Wal-Mart's never-ending mantra: Low Prices
As many of you can probably tell, this week I've switched to using Wal-Mart's newest logo, about a year after the world's largest retailer actually started using it. In 2007, Wal-Mart changed from "Always Low Prices" to "Save Money. Live Better" as its corporate slogan. The change became part of the retailer's logo as well. Wal-Mart said throughout 2006 and into 2007 that it no longer wanted to be perceived as a "low price" stalwart that only catered to those focused on price and nothing else. In other words, lower-income shoppers and families looking to clothe and feed themselves and their families with the lowest amount of money possible.
What Wal-Mart may not have anticipated, though, was that energy prices, gas prices, and some food prices would skyrocket and plunge a whole new contingent of American citizens into the consumer group that would start seeking out lower prices and money-saving deals at all costs. In fact, the retailer mentioned this in its most recent quarterly results.
Although Wal-Mart wanted to cater to higher-income shoppers with newer product lines, enhanced store designs and higher-margin goods, the one saving grace can be its focus on supplying just about any product on its shelves at the absolute lowest price available to ensure it "saves the customer money" and retains that loyalty for when economic times get tough. Well, in case you haven't noticed, economic times have indeed gotten tough in 2008 -- and Wal-Mart is doing something about it on the web.
Helping consumers stretch that dollar like a piece of cheap rubber
Wal-Mart has partnered with Ellie Kay, a family financial expert, to help consumers make wise spending decisions and stretch their dollars at a new website: savemore.walmartstores.com. Wal-Mart wants to ensure it can teach customers how to save as much money as possible by really seeking out bargains as well as using tried-and-true shopping methodologies to cut down on those expenses that are being eaten alive by high gas prices and tightened personal credit standards.
Wal-Mart's new savings website has money-saving tips, video podcasts that demonstrate these tips, chats from Wal-Mart executives on future moves the retailer will make to save you money, and more. One of the biggest pieces of the new website is the capability for consumers to enter and display their own money-saving tips. Opening up the floor to your customer base is always the best idea: give the customer the outlet and let them run the show while you run the platform. This is the basic idea behind blogging in a sense: generate stickiness among the readership and invite them to participate in the dialog as much as possible, like a genuine townhall-type conversation.
But don't think Wal-Mart is doing this as a public service only: it plugs itself all over the website as an enticement to recruit ever more shoppers being plagued by high prices on so many needed daily items -- like gas and milk for starters. The retailer also has an entire section of the website dedicated to informing consumers about all of the money services Wal-Mart offers. Areas like check cashing services, ATM cards, money centers, check cashing, bill payments and money transfers are all broken down and explained in-depth. Hey -- you already shop at Wal-Mart, so why not take advantage of its full-service financial services as well?
The problem with Wal-Mart's marketing of this program
Although Wal-Mart provides an easy way on the website to share it/send it to friends (online viral marketing), it is going to take more than that to reach the mainstream Wal-Mart consumer and let them know the breadth of tips and information available. I am a firm believer that Wal-Mart market its unique value propositions directly in stores. Take some of that signage inventory and really get the daily Wal-Mart shopper knowledgeable about a new money-saving website and the value it could bring to them. Perhaps Wal-Mart has this planned, but I saw no mention of this new website in three different Wal-Mart stores I visited this past week.
Some of the tips offered at the website are basic financial warnings: save money by saving, budget your expenses, beware certain types of debt consolidation and so on. These are truths that have been espoused forever in the consumer finance world, and now Wal-Mart is telling its consumers that there are indeed great maxims to live by. That's great -- but the impact will be small unless you advertise and market the website inside your biggest (and free) advertising vehicle: your own store locations.
Wal-Mart is looking as this as a promotional offshoot of www.walmart.com, but it has to reach further. There must be millions of shoppers who visit Wal-Mart several times per week but who rarely visit Wal-Mart's website. These are the customers Wal-Mart needs to reach with a decent frequency if it really wants to get the concept of "Save Money. Live Better" to the majority of its customers. I'll be watching to see if it in fact does this.
It may be true that Wal-Mart doesn't usually pitch its promotions in stores, while saving that venue for product education and price. That's all well and good, but I fail to see the logic on not pitching for a valuable online resource that could be of real value to the majority of its consumers. Wal-Mart, let me know your thinking if you can, because I'm not sure I understand your thinking on using your stores to get more customers to one of your websites (that is, not a website that will compete with your foot traffic).
Hope you enjoyed this week's Wal-Mart Weekly. Stay tuned right here next week for another edition, and until then, have a great week!











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
5-19-2008 @ 2:00AM
B. Harrison said...
WalMart, otherwise known as "ChinaMart", is doing it's damnedest to increase its business and to increase our balance of trade payments to China.
Whatever happened to WalMart's founder, Sam Walton's motto of "MADE IN THE USA"? After Sam died things certainly changed for the worse, didn't it.
For every dollar "saved" at WalMart/"ChinaMart", how many dollars are added to our imbalance of trade deficit to China, and how much more is the U.S. dollar devalued by? "Savings" at WalMart/"ChinaMart" equates to the slow long run strangulation of our economy, and our American way of life.
Since the year 2000, the U.S. dollar has been devalued by approximately 50%, due in large part to our imbalance in our trade deficit. Is every fifty cents of "theorectical savings" at WalMart/"ChinaMart" really costing Americans a full dollar or two . . . or more . . . in the long run. Americans can see what appears to be "savings' with each purchase; but the insideous continuned greater devaluation of the American dollar is "invisible" to the WalMart/"ChinaMart" customers.
The Amercian standard of living is going to continue to erode unless the imbalance of trade is reduced.
5-19-2008 @ 4:07AM
Nancy said...
I have found, during the past month, Walmart's prices to be much HIGHER than the competition: Meijer, Target, Walgreens, & local grocery stores by a fairly high number: not just higher by a few cents, but in many cases by over a dollar.
Walmart's milk prices for example were much higher. Cereal was higher, soft drinks, even paper towels. Even M& M's were $1.29 higher for a medium size bag at walmart compared to Walgreens.
Over the counter medications and vitamins were cheaper at Meijer.
I think when they started the $4.00 prescription dug deal, they raised the prices of everything else.
It used to be you could count on walmart for the best deal--NOT ANYMORE--if you don't know your prices, DO NO GO TO WALMART. I don't have time to waste, so I will go to Meijer.
PS. I have family in walmart management & I still am done shopping there
5-19-2008 @ 12:20PM
Mari said...
I live near Wichita Kansas and my name for Wal Mart is Wal Mart Fall Apart. Much of the stuff they sell is junk.
I read when they had a great 3rd quarter in earnings but one store on Maize Rd. is not getting a bonus because of the "bottom line" Not sure what that is but I do know the store does well in sales so why no bonus.
I figure that Wal Mart just takes a list of the stores and just checks off so many - no bonus - and that is a little more money for them.
Don't like Wal Mart, try very hard not to shop there and very selfom do. Won't eat any meat they sell or produce and not sure I would eat at the deli.
5-19-2008 @ 12:34PM
madmilker said...
quote***In China, as elsewhere, we follow the Wal-Mart tradition of building our business one store and one customer at a time. We strive to provide our customers with friendly service and a wide selection of quality products at Every Day Low Prices. With each Wal-Mart store we bring advanced retail know-how to the local market. By fostering a healthy, competitive environment, we hope to constantly improve our business operations and customer service in order to contribute to the prosperity of the local economy.
Wal-Mart firmly believes in local procurement. We recognize that by purchasing quality products, we can generate more job opportunities, support local manufacturing and boost economic development. Over 95% of the merchandise in our stores in China is sourced locally. We have established partnerships with nearly 20,000 suppliers in China. At Wal-Mart, we always work with our suppliers to grow together. In August 2007, Wal-Mart once again secured the top spot of the 2007 Supplier Satisfaction Survey conducted by Business Information of Shanghai. Additionally, Wal-Mart directly exports about US$9 billion from China every year. The export volume by third party suppliers is also estimated to be over US$9 billion.***end quote!
now! the largest company in America is a 5 & 10 cent store and they make "nothing"....the second largest is the government and the only thing they make is more debt.
The company that at one time had a hyphen in the name now has a single big star and they put 95% China items in the China stores and support China export.....but in America they do all most the same and have very little American made. So! the American consumer buys the foreign items and the US dollars goes overseas.....with America not making anything for the nice foreigners to buy... the government sells the American debt......the company makes the nice people of China support made in China and their currency(yuan) stays strong... but in America the US dollar declines all the while Uncle Sam and the American consumer goes farther in debt. The Wal*Mart today.....is not the same Wal-Mart of yesterday.....and that's sad!
5-20-2008 @ 5:10PM
Mari said...
This is Mari again:
I must correct myself as I have discovered that the store that was not getting a bonus is now getting a $40.00 bonus for part time worklers. How great is that!!!!!!! Will that fill your gas tank?