Icahn is right this time: Yahoo! CEO Jerry Yang must go

As Paul Foster wrote yesterday, The Wall Street Journal [subscription] is reporting that corporate raider Carl Icahn will seek to replace Yahoo! Inc. (NASDAQ: YHOO) co-founder and CEO Jerry Yang at the company's next shareholders meeting in early August. Although Icahn is generally outspoken and sometimes makes brash statements, he's right on this one. Here's why.

Yang created a 100-day plan in 2007 when he replaced outgoing CEO Terry Semel. It involved finding out why Yahoo! was not as successful as it should be, re-aligning priorities for profit goals and heralding that there were no "sacred cows" when it comes to Yahoo! finding its mojo again. The company -- a year later -- is floundering and has not made any progress in finding profitability growth in the face of Google, Inc. (NASDAQ: GOOG). It's unfortunate that Yahoo! is constantly compared to Google, which reigns supreme in internet search, but that is the sandbox Yahoo! is playing in.

So, if Icahn's bid to control Yahoo!'s board is successful, his first order of business would be to oust Yang, the person responsible for Yahoo!'s unsuccess in the last year and the person who torpedoed Microsoft Corp.'s (NASDAQ: MSFT) bid take over the company earlier this year. Microsoft gave up in May as Yahoo! wanted a $37 per share buyout, which would have valued Yahoo! at over $47 billion.