The prestigious 2008 No Kidding! Award For Obviousness in Financial Journalism goes to the Associated Press for this headline: GM's recovery depends on winning over car buyers.Ya don't say? And here I was thinking it depended on the Yen carry trade.
But in a way, that headline is a wonderfully succinct illustration of why the odds of a successful turnaround at General Motors (NYSE: GM) are basically zero. The company has a crippling debt load and a cost structure that isn't even close to being competitive with the infinitely leaner Asian automakers which, by the way, make cars that are more relevant.
GM brass are sounding an optimistic note on their upcoming car introductions, and maybe they will improve. But the company has a difficult task: slash costs while restoring the company's brand positions. Either of those would be difficult, and both at the same time is probably impossible. The company is at a competitive disadvantage that is simply massive, and its decline has gained additional momentum from the decline of its brand equity. If GM didn't already exist, people would laugh at the idea: "Let's have a huge debt load and a really high cost structure and sell cars that are almost as good as our foreign competitors."
When I think about it like that, it's hard to find a reason to even consider investing in the company's stock.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
7-17-2008 @ 10:30AM
Greg said...
GM has managed to do what the US steel industry did: conciliate themselves into an untenable cost position. The UAW workers killed the goose that laid the golden egg by demanding (and the automaker acceding to) huge pay and benefits contracts. At the time, and so many years ago, it seemed just a good deal; who could have foreseen the rise of foreign competition with low cost labor? But that is the case, and there seems no going back. Is that not the historic case? I’m sure people mourned the passing of the horse and buggy, but life moved on and the auto became king of the road, and many more profited greatly. Retraining and new educational routed were required, but were introduced at a leisurely pace. The passing of GM, probably Chrysler and maybe even Ford will be mourned, and the re-education of the UAW workers will proceed at far greater pace, bringing greater levels of stress. Thirty years from now few will remember the pain, or care. In fifty, new problems will be in the headlines and the old workers retired or passed away. I can’t imagine what transportation will be like in the America of 2108.
7-17-2008 @ 11:44AM
bob lemmond said...
g.m. is still the worlds largest car seller.