
Thanks to their thin layer of capital, lenders are rationing access to debt that is contributing to a decline in housing prices. Bloomberg News reports they've fallen 15.3% in the last year in the 20 largest cities, and one estimate suggests that $6 trillion in housing wealth will evaporate in 2008.
Meanwhile, automobiles have lost so much value that Chrysler announced that it would quit leasing its vehicles because their trade-in value was not sufficient to keep the leases profitable, according to The New York Times. The loss of this financing business is a major blow.
In January 2006 I pointed out that the automobile companies were making their money on financing and the vehicles were simply a life support system for the money lending. Houses performed a similar function for the mortgage finance industry. Financing has become the tail that wags the dog.
And now that financing has dried up for houses and cars, the industries that make them are suffering catastrophic losses -- Ford Motor Co. (NYSE: F) just announced an $8.7 billion net loss -- $2.1 billion of that was related to unprofitable leases according to the New York Times. Thanks to their inefficient use of gas, SUVs have far lower resale values than car companies anticipated.
Eventually, prices and supply will drop enough that demand will revive. But with the absence of financing, the prices at which supply and demand will come back into equilibrium could be much lower than they were just a year ago. Our declining use of debt and gasoline is likely to continue to produce painful economic withdrawal pangs.
Peter Cohan is President of Peter S. Cohan & Associates. He also teaches management at Babson College and edits The Cohan Letter











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
7-27-2008 @ 10:27AM
william lindblad said...
I agree with most of this post but I think the word "eventually", with regard to demand could be further in the future than currently assumed.
Problems with heating fuel costs are going to range over most of the U.S. Congress is working on a package of subsidy and possibly another round of incentives.
While the exact details of the recent housing assistance package are yet to be reviewed by the press, some of this has become public. The segment regarding the two F's proves interesting. Bail out funds are provided along with stipulations regarding exec. pay levels and a call for a new oversight agency with more "teeth"". The bill also includes higher cost levels for government backed mortgage notes. I believe that the old cap was around 417,000. Since you don't mind going out on lilmb, you should take a look. I don't like what I see. First, we have a financial mess and the only culprits so far are some rumor mongers and some investigations into hedge funds and lending practice. All of the oversight responsibility rested in Congress and government agency and this housing assistance package seems to be an effort to avoid any direct investigations.
Why does Congress wish to avoid asking the heads of the OFHEO how this happend? The same for the heads of Fannie and Freddie?
Why are we raising the mortgage cap above the 417,000 level? Is this because the two F's are carrying jumbo's that they were not supposed to?
Perhaps there are no questions because there are too many people involved and to much would come to light with public hearings.
7-27-2008 @ 2:06PM
gumbo koontz said...
some americans really worship at gas pumps as you know.. lets look at a regular week.. That american drive alone to work , then goes up to mountain to ski on weekends (almost every weekend) he has a snowmobile there and he frequent at gas pumps all over .. Come to think of that. Some americans are really high consumptive types! Without gasoline, they will end up in mental wards, willnt they? maybe they ought to pay a visit to a shrink or what/??
7-27-2008 @ 2:06PM
gumbo koontz said...
some americans really worship at gas pumps as you know.. lets look at a regular week.. That american drive alone to work , then goes up to mountain to ski on weekends (almost every weekend) he has a snowmobile there and he frequent at gas pumps all over .. Come to think of that. Some americans are really high consumptive types! Without gasoline, they will end up in mental wards, willnt they? maybe they ought to pay a visit to a shrink or what/??
7-27-2008 @ 2:10PM
gumbo koontz said...
There is still so many Americans around who think that they can still afford $4 gasoline or even $6. They still buy new SUVs and PickUps because those sales has not exactly cratered at all just down 30% or so. Those Americans dont seem to care about other poor Americans who are praying by bedside for a return to $2 gasoline. Praise the Lord! We will have $2 gasoline back and the wealthy infidels will be burned to ashes!! alleuia!
7-27-2008 @ 2:11PM
gumbo koontz said...
There is still so many Americans around who think that they can still afford $4 gasoline or even $6. They still buy new SUVs and PickUps because those sales has not exactly cratered at all just down 30% or so. Those Americans dont seem to care about other poor Americans who are praying by bedside for a return to $2 gasoline. Praise the Lord! We will have $2 gasoline back and the wealthy infidels will be burned to ashes!! alleuia!
7-27-2008 @ 2:22PM
gumbo koontz said...
Maybe we should start rationing gasoline to all Americans even if he doesnt have a car . He can sell his rations for any price he commands. Suppose you are stranded with no rations left, you can still buy gasoline at much higher prices. This way we can keep supply and demand balance on a predictable basis and keep Big Oil from messin' with our economy anymore. We had our fills with Big Oil because Big Oil is so big like an elephant thrasing our tents when things are not going right. Our government can issue special credit cards with rations of , say, 1000 gallons a year that we can insert in gas pumps. We will be forced to decide whether to carpool, operate a RV or a yacht, gas generators or vacation trips. Sure , parents can be issued 100 extra gallons for each kid as an exemption. it is much like your utiltiy bill with price brackets starting with first 15 therms a month at lowest price and escalalte to higher brackets as your utility consumpiton goes up. Your utility already dont care how big your house or small your apartement is. They charge you at various prices... Why cant we do same thing with Big Oil?? We just cant drill out of our oil problem ever again... it is 2008 not 1940's... 7 billion dudes live on Earth already...
7-28-2008 @ 12:24AM
robrt lipton said...
lets give two year leases at anwar with drilling commitment..and remind nancy pelosi that her approval rating lower than bush...it mirrors her IQ
7-28-2008 @ 11:01AM
ekrabs said...
I would think a smart survivalist would move to a more temperate climate....
7-28-2008 @ 12:14PM
jpdr1100 said...
Lipton,
In Alaska, the National Petroleum Reserve/Alaska, directly to the west of the National Wildlife Refuge, has over three times as much projected oil reserves as the Wildlife Refuge, and has close access to current pipelines. The 24-million-acre NPR/A is completely open to leasing, 4 million acres are already leased, but the oil companies have yet to produce a drop of oil there. Clearly, oil companies already have more acreage under lease than they choose to develop, and their record profits certainly allow them to invest in equipment and refineries they might need. Instead, they want to hoard more leases and drive prices even higher.