In this series, we take a look at the 25 stocks on the S&P 500 Index (SPX) that have turned in the worst performance during the past decade -- what went wrong, and what happens next.
Former hippies might notice that the ticker symbol for Tenet Healthcare Corporation (NYSE: THC) is also the acronym for the active compound in marijuana, but this apparent inattention to detail is likely the least of the company's concerns. When Tenet was formed in 1995, it was born out of a merger between American Medical International and scandal-plagued National Medical Enterprises. Executives at the newly reborn healthcare services company hoped that its new name would help erase any unpleasant investor associations with its previous incarnation.
What went wrong? At number 19 on our list of SPX losers, THC shed 73% of its value during the 10-year period ending June 30, 2008. Prior to a stomach-churning sell-off in the fall of 2002, the shares were entrenched in a near-vertical uptrend that peaked at $52.50. It seems that a seedy healthcare services company by any other name ...
October 2002 marked the stock's peak, as well as the beginning of its steep descent. First, the company reported fiscal first-quarter earnings that surpassed analysts' estimates by 2 cents per share. A few weeks later, Tenet was named co-defendant in a lawsuit filed by the widow of a man who'd accepted an artificial heart, which she alleged "stripped him of his human dignity." This relatively minor suit, worth just $100,000, wouldn't break THC -- but it nonetheless heralded the beginning of the end. Toward the end of the month, the shares tumbled sharply after an analyst downgraded Tenet and warned that it was too dependent on Medicare reimbursements from the government.
Well, let's just hope that analyst's boss gave him a nice holiday bonus. Faster than you can ask, "Did somebody say Medicare?" -- on October 31, 2002, to be exact -- one of Tenet's California hospitals was raided by federal investigators. The government alleged that THC was guilty of Medicare fraud, and that its hospitals encouraged patients to undergo unnecessary and invasive coronary procedures in order to line their taxpayer-funded coffers. It turned out the feds weren't just following a crazy hunch; the Justice Department rang in 2003 by filing a fresh $323-million lawsuit against Tenet. In the quarters to come, investors learned that THC wasn't nearly so profitable minus the trumped-up Medicare payments.
What next? THC has never been able to recover from its rather massive Medicare faux pas. Following the stock's sharp plunge in late 2002, its price action leveled out into a slow and steady, consistent downtrend. More recently, the shares have been stabilizing around $5.50. However, in light of its years-long downtrend and bargain-basement price, one can't help but wonder if THC's days on the SPX aren't numbered (insert your own tasteless life support joke here).
Elizabeth Harrow is an analyst and financial writer in the research department at Schaeffer's Investment Research. She is featured in the weekly video series Option Basics on SchaeffersResearch.com.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
7-25-2008 @ 1:40PM
Tommy said...
Im an outside contractor,aka registry aka nurse Rt etc. Tenet makes all employees and outside contract employees take a 4 hour exam on ethics as a result of the lack of ethics yearly, of the managers.
Rediculous! This is like traffic laws. Do you notice how lawful you drive when theres a cop behind you vs when ones not in sight? Thats a hospital situation.Audits are rare so its business as usual until then.
7-27-2008 @ 5:02PM
bob taylor said...
what happens to us poor fools who worked long
enough to earn a monetary retirement? do we
have to have our retirement run out when the
company folds? oh, if i had only known what a
black guard of a company THC would become
back when i decided to continue working for
them until i retired!!!