The New York Times reports that underneath the failure of Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. (NYSE: LEH) was a desire by its CEO to get more money for his company than the Korean Development Bank was willing to pay. The reason Richard Fuld wanted more was that he was in a state of denial about reality. And that's a common problem facing successful people all over -- one I call confirmation bias -- in which a decision-maker ignores information that is not consistent with his or her world view.
And that is the beauty of a system of free markets in which there is complete transparency of costs and benefits and participants win and lose on the merits of their strategies. Until this weekend, the government had been operating under a scheme of private profits and nationalized losses. In other words, the taxpayer footed the bill for those multi-million compensation packages for the executives who generated the losses.
But with the government's decision to let the private sector live with the consequences of its bad decisions, we are getting closer to a free market system. Such a system would create powerful incentives for a vigilant attitude towards rapidly changing reality by managers -- such as John Thain -- who could see that Merrill Lynch & Co.. (NYSE: MER) would follow in Lehman's footsteps absent a deal. And if we had a system that solved the five flaws in our financial architecture, we could truly benefit from a system of free markets in the future.
Peter Cohan is President of Peter S. Cohan & Associates. He also teaches management at Babson College and edits The Cohan Letter. He has no financial interest in the securities mentioned.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
9-16-2008 @ 11:55AM
john said...
This idea that we should stand and cheer as these financial giants go down in flames because the Fed has quit bailing them out(maybe) is nonsense.
What you have here is the Herbert Hoover defense of free markets. ugh ugh.
A properly regulated industry would have avoided this catastrophe but as you know, some in this country think any regulation of any kind is bad. Now we are finding out what "bad" really is.
9-16-2008 @ 1:25PM
David Hustom said...
Careful about sounding victory for free enterprise over socialized losses: the government is reportedly considering some form of bailout for AIG as you speak.