Normally, I'm the kind of person who thinks it's ridiculous when investors sell in a bear market. I didn't flinch when the dot-come bubble burst, or in the downturn after the terrorist attacks. But this time is different. In January, I pulled back my stock holdings to the low end of the asset allocation models. In the last couple weeks as the credit crunch unfurled while I was on vacation in Canada with my husband, I looked for an up day in the market to sell. On Friday, I cut our stock holdings in our regular and retirement accounts by about one-third.
On Friday afternoon I completely expected the market Monday to rise on word of a successful bailout. I warned my husband that there would certainly be a rally when the deal was approved and we would lose out. Boy, did that turn out not to be the case. It still may happen, but I really doubt it will completely erase Monday's loss.
Friday wasn't even my first choice for a sell date. As I said, we were traveling and the two other times I wanted to sell, we couldn't get a secure internet connection in time.
I still don't believe I've timed this perfectly. You just can't. If I had timed it perfectly I would've taken everything out of stocks last October. I could have saved around 20-30% of my holdings with that. And I'm absolutely certain that I won't jump back in at exactly the right time. I know the market lurches up in big jumps.
But I don't need to get it 100% right to save myself some money. When the market has been up lately, it's been on that crazy market wisdom that, 'Yeah! A bailout plan is coming!' But the big picture is still bad news: A bailout is needed and even it may not work.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
9-30-2008 @ 1:56PM
Jeff said...
I sold QID on Monday and bought some stocks with the proceeds. It wasn't luck.
10-01-2008 @ 1:17AM
Shelley said...
Selling should not be about luck. And it should not come so late in the game. It takes alot of training and experience to know how to evaluate a stock's behavior and overall market conditions in order to determine the best exit plan for your position. Plus it takes tremendous time and energy to be constantly monitoring the markets and determining the necessary course of adjustments needed to truly "let profits run while cutting losses". That's why SMARTSTOPS.net was created. To help any investor deploy a sophisticated, intelligent exit strategy to any stock position regardless of where you entered. The market does not care where you entered. What all investors need to learn is that the portfolio diversification and re-balancing aren't enough. That risk management requires a much more active approach. The markets no longer operate as in previous generations where Buy&Hold could be a safe strategy. Just look at the studies done on our website. You may be surprised to learn that Buy&Hold is the riskiest strategy around.
http://www.smartstops.net