The cover of today's New York Daily News loudly proclaimed the joy and wonder, the shock and awe of yesterday's Wall Street rally. Right beside the headline, in the middle of a huge red arrow marked "Dow soars to biggest point gain in history," the paper presented a picture of a trader, both thumbs up, sporting a cocky, devil-may-care smile. Inside, the paper carried another shot of its leering cover boy, this time accompanied by another trader sporting a mindless grin.It was hardly necessary to read the accompanying article, as the pictures told the whole tale: the stock market, after plummeting for a few days, more or less hit bottom. Other countries started pouring money into their banks, calming the panic, and enabling investors to remember that the paper they were passing back and forth sometimes represented actual value. When this happened, the investors proceeded to start buying some of their stock back at ever-increasing rates, causing the Dow Jones index to rapidly rise. Of course, the next few acts in this play are equally obvious: the market will continue to fluctuate as irrational exuberance and irrational caution trade places and seek equilibrium in the Wall Street version of manic depression.
For some people, the wild fluctuations of the market will translate into equally wild emotional rides. In the United States, the land where Calvinism never died, wealth is still considered a sign of rectitude and poverty a mark of weakness. It naturally follows, then, that the relative ebb and flow of our economic fortunes will translate into a similar roller coaster of pride and self-doubt. One need look no further than the cover of the Daily News to see a man who takes responsibility for the strength of the market and, presumably, blames himself for its failings. As stock market players continue to confuse knowledge of the market with the ability to control it, their sense of self will rise and fall with its fluctuations.
The flip side of the unknown trader's BOOYA! grin is a brutal depression, a condition noted by the Reverend Canon Ann Malonee. As the vicar at Trinity Church, the storied house of worship located at the intersection of Broadway and Wall Street, Canon Malonee is something of a spiritual first responder for the financial district. With regard to the recent panic, she stated "I've had a number of people say that this is [...] reminiscent of 9/11," noting that "It's that sense of having the rug pulled out from under them."
Just as the financial crisis has had effects far beyond the environs of Wall Street, the ensuing depression has also spread across the country, leading to a rise in suicides and "mercy killings," as families have realized that they will no longer be able to stay in their homes. In the process, many people facing foreclosure have also turned to suicide hotlines, counseling services, and other community organizations, quickly overwhelming these resources.
According to some experts, this sense of malaise and helplessness is, ironically, having a negative effect on the economy. As a recent CNN poll noted, 60% of Americans think that an economic depression is "likely" to occur in the near future. While economists strongly disagree, many have noted that this widespread perception will actually exacerbate the forthcoming recession. As consumers hoard their money and prepare for the worst, the cuts in expenditures will result in reduced jobs and greater economic hardship. Under the circumstances, it seems like the grin sported by the Daily News' unknown trader may have more power to control the economy than any rational thought he might produce!











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
10-15-2008 @ 6:04AM
Dan Barnett said...
The psychological aspect to economic activity has been long known. "The only thing we have to fear..." & this is why the President has been the Cheerleader-in-Chief recently.
The "Prophets of Profit" may propound a religious doctrine of wealth accumulation.
But I am not sure of their doctrines in a down market.
Perhaps we should look at the times of the Black Death to see the reactions of a society abandoned by its' God.