The first struggle has been to come up with a name for the Wall Street meltdown (I still like "Bernanke Panky"). However, as that plays out, it's time to begin finding a villain to blame. This is tremendously important stuff. For history to be written, complex events must be boiled down to a single cause, preferably an individual who can take responsibility for everything. For example, as every schoolchild knows, LBJ caused Vietnam, Hoover caused the Great Depression, and Nixon caused Watergate. Never mind that these men were the products of their ages or that history is a complex process. Children need villains, history demands explanations, and Americans crave resolution. Never mind that millions of homeowners signed up for mortgages that they couldn't pay, that millions of investors blindly purchased worthless securities, and that the groundwork for this disaster was laid by Democrats and Republicans demonstrating an impressive, albeit bipartisan, ignorance. History must be written and blame must be laid. Chances are, it will end up falling on one of the following people:
Richard Fuld
Although Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. (NYSE: LEMQ), was only one of the firms involved in the subprime mess, Fuld has taken an outsized blame for the economy's downfall. The reason for this might be his aristocratic demeanor or his cadaverous profile, but it's more likely that detractors are struck by his impressive blame-shifting. In his testimony before Congress, Fuld's willingness to accept responsibility for Lehman was tempered by his complaints about the government's refusal to bail out his company. Moreover, in a fantastic demonstration of corporate greed, he bickered with Rep. Henry Waxman about his pay: Waxman claimed it was $480 million over the past eight years, while Fuld claimed it was "only" $60 million.
On the other hand, Fuld is also responsible for one of the few bright spots of the past month: when it was announced that Lehman Brothers was going under, Fuld went to the company's gym, where one of his employees punched him out. Across the country, millions cheered.
Hank Paulson
On the surface, Hank Paulson is a tough sell: working ceaselessly over the past month, he has been begging Congress for funds while trying to figure out how best to bail out the economy. In fact, he would appear almost blameless, were he not a former Wall Street tycoon who brought home $700 million from his years of working at Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. (NYSE: GS). Moreover, the original bailout plan gave Paulson near-Napoleonic levels of power and his later claim that he was unaware of the unconstitutionality of his proposal seems questionable. While Paulson isn't directly responsible for the current meltdown, it's pretty clear that he is firmly ensconced in the environment that created it.
Christian Milton (AIG)
American International Group, Inc. (NYSE: AIG) has emerged as the villain of choice in the current crisis. Unfortunately, it's emotionally unsatisfying to blame a company; lacking a human face, AIG is sort of like the "Liberal Media" or the "Military-Industrial Complex," a broad-reaching boogeyman that is good for scaring people but isn't really all that easy to pin down.
Even so, with its $500,000 retreats, $86,000 hunting trips, AIG is practically a poster boy for corporate greed, and its reinsurance head, Christian Milton, is the first of the company's employees to find his way to the gallows. Between 1982 and 2005, Milton committed conspiracy, securities fraud, mail fraud, and made false statements to the SEC. Under federal sentencing guidelines, he may go to jail for the remainder of his life. Granted, he was tried in February, but AIG is a big, juicy target and Milton is a handy felon.
Of course, this is only a partial list. In time, some will blame Ben Bernanke, others will hold Hank Greenberg responsible, and a few will lay responsibility at the doorstep of George Bush. In the meantime, however, these three men are a good place to start the orgy of recrimination that will dominate the news until football playoff season or the next big disaster.
The Money Man Behind Rick Santorum: Who Is Foster S. Friess?
Savings Experiment: Snow Removal


Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
10-22-2008 @ 5:40PM
Stocks said...
I think you can blame the democrats and Bill Clinton for the Freddie May and Fannie Mac disasters, which was a huge contributor to this, and then the banking industry in general for making such stupid risky investments based solely on short term gains and greed. I think these people should be hung from the lamp posts, because what they have done is criminal in the extreme.
http://stocksbuyorsell.com
10-22-2008 @ 6:47PM
JCH said...
It's laughable to blame F&F on Democrats and Bill Clinton.
The architects of this disaster are George Bush, Karl Rove, and Alan Greenspan.
Bernanke took over the Fed in 2006. In 2006 he issued guidelines that virtually ended exotic subprime lending. No act of congress was required. The President did not have to be consulted. He initiated regulatory authority over mortgage lending that was given to the Federal Reserve by the Clinton Administration in 1994. Greenspan could have done it in 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, and 2005. He refuse while citing pop Ayn Rand lunacy.
The vast majority of the foreclosures during the Bush administration involved subprime loans that were originated by private-sector entities that lay outside CRA requirements, and were originated between 2002 and 2006.
10-22-2008 @ 6:51PM
ATHELSTAN said...
The usual advice in a strong bear market--which is perfectly good advice in most instances--is "buy on the dips".. In this case, however, it is best to buy when you hear the rumble of hundreds of thousands pouring into the streets, the fire of howitzers can be heard in the distance, the smell of burning buildings hangs heavy in the air, and those bodies of investment bankers and hedge fund managers start falling from the heights of the Chrysler Bldg. Now that is REALLY "buying on the dips".
An alternative is to simply dollar cost average into banks and financial stocks irrespective of the economic conditions.
10-22-2008 @ 7:13PM
Liam said...
To the guy who said blame the democrats... I think they are the ones who have been trying to rein in this extreme, unchecked form of capitalism. Yes, there is greed and short-terminism, that is the nature of investment banking and stockbroking. So, presumably, you can't blame the companies and businessmen involved, even though they may have been reckless. So you blame the goverment.
Takes a leap of logic to not blame the guy who was had been pushing for deregulation for his whole two years of his presidency, whose party backed him. Clinton and the Democrats kept a leash on them, and it worked. Bush changed all that.
10-22-2008 @ 8:39PM
Gary said...
We all talk about the economy of this country like it is someones in particular fault. Get a life all you! The fault of the failure lays with us all. We elected the government officials to watch over us and our money. We are the ones who stood back and said that this would never happen in America. We are the ones who spent large sums of money when we thought this were OK. But did we ever really check to see the inside and what was happening. Come on folks. You can blame who ever you want if it make you feel good. But, the truth of the matter is it is our fault and no one else's... We let the banks go unchecked. We paid the outragious low morgage payments to get a home we really could not affford. All of a sudden banks could not make there own payments to the central banks because of idiots lending money that was not there. All the time we thought everything was OK. B.S. folks, this was a long time coming and when it hit you are all looking for a scape goat to cover your own stupid mistakes...
10-22-2008 @ 9:23PM
Anne said...
Excuse me, but where the heck did that 700 billion dollars go, anyway?
10-22-2008 @ 11:38PM
Ferrarigtc said...
Must we not forget Sheila Bair and Jaime Dimon during the whole seizure. The following the week the market crashed.
10-22-2008 @ 11:40PM
Ferrarigtc said...
Must we not forget Sheila Bair and Jaime Dimon during the whole seizure. The following the week the market crashed.
10-23-2008 @ 12:33AM
Mace said...
The Democrat written and passed "Community Reinvestment Act" is to blame. This was Carter's doing that required giving bad loans mostly to "people of color." It was modified to be worse under Clinton. The banks were first encouraged then basically forced to give bad loans. Then Freddie and Fanny pioneered the practice of securitizing the bad mortgages to spread the risk. Democrats like Barney Frank and Maxine Waters fought against regulating these GSE's. If the Fed had not kept the interest rates artificially low creating a housing bubble, the bad loans would have been foreclosed, end of story. But the Fed fueled the housing bubble and now it came crashing down all at once.
10-23-2008 @ 1:41AM
sc said...
that's the race-baiting nonsense that republicans are trying to indoctrinate the world with. yet more reprehensible behavior on the part of the conservatives. the CRA was involved in only 20-25% of the subprime loans,the other 75-80% of the subprime were by morgage lenders.
"A national study of the performance of Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) covered banks concludes, "CRA Banks were substantially less likely than other lenders to make the kinds of risky home purchase loans that helped fuel the foreclosure crisis. CRA Banks were significantly less likely than other lenders to make a high cost loan. The average APR on high cost loans originated by CRA Banks was appreciably lower than the average APR on high cost loans originated by other lenders; CRA Banks were more than twice as likely as other lenders to retain originated loans in their portfolio." http://www.traigerlaw.com/publications/traiger_hinckley_llp_cra_foreclosure_study_1-7-08.pdf
republicans love to preach "take responsibility for your action, but they have not taken responsibility for the trickle down, cut taxes AND REGULATIONS mantra they have been blowing in our collective ear for the past 30 years.
10-23-2008 @ 4:07AM
fred said...
"Anne said...
Excuse me, but where the heck did that 700 billion dollars go, anyway?"
10% of the $700 billion bailout to be footed by U.S. taxpayers is projected to go to the pay and bonuses of Wall Street bankers.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2008/oct/17/executivesalaries-banking
10-23-2008 @ 5:05AM
BHarrison said...
The unequivocal "censorship" being exercised by AOL by the selective deltion of various comments is uncoscionable. For example, they have selectively deleted previous comments to this article.
Who is it in AOL that is empowered to "censor" legitimate and relevant comments, and what is the basis for such censorship? I consider this to be worrisome for ALL Americans.
10-23-2008 @ 5:53AM
Mike Sanders said...
I have wondered about the "censorship" rules, too. I've had all kinds of things happen to me, but the most interesting happened a week or two ago, when I asked a friend to go look at my comments (and vote). I gave her the link, with the exact timestamps and even said to sort "ascending," since it was near the beginning of the file... She could not find my messages and said that there was a gap from the timestamp before each message, to after. OK, no big deal, I've had my messages edited out before... What burns me, is that when I went back to look, they were there! It was like my version was "journalized" and had the missing comments restored, so I would think that they were still there, but the "world" didn't see them! Talk about sneaky! The Mission Impossible guys couldn't have done a better job! Michael R. Sanders (retired from EDS, but still vigilant.)
10-23-2008 @ 6:55AM
3018c133 said...
I think these guys should have their assest seized and sold to pay for the bailout.The tax payer gets the bill for these guys greed and Congress doesnt have the backbone to do anything about it except to haul them in front of Congress and chastise them.These guys are laughing all the way to the bank.Really wants me to pay my taxes
10-23-2008 @ 9:57AM
Virgil Bierschwale said...
If you're looking for someone to blame.
A scapegoat..
Then blame each and every one of us as we caused this mess and we need to step up to the plate and deal with it.
Take a look at my latest You Tube video titled "The Sky is Falling" on my web site at http://www.KeepAmericaAtWork.com
Until we stop looking for a scapegoat and realize that our greed and our willingness to sell the rope that will be used to hang ourselves, well lets just say that the person that is at fault is all of us.
Virgil
http://www.KeepAmericaAtWork.com
10-23-2008 @ 10:31AM
beachpaul said...
The Republicans wanted deregulation. They have won the majority of the elections the past twenty five years. Majority rules in America. The Republicans, got what they, the majority, wanted. Next time, make sure, we really know and understand what it is we really want. Because in, America, sometimes, we really can get what we want.
11-12-2008 @ 7:29PM
Tony Cortese said...
The real crooks are the ones on Wall Street , George Bush, Dick Cheney, andDonald Rumsfeld . With Obama at the helm, CEO's will get less compensations and the deployment of troops will free up monies to help stimulate the economy. The days of GREED will be gone. The new money revolution is beginning.