The Treasury bailout, getting private equity involved

It is a bad idea because it will slow the process of getting money from the Treasury to needy firms. That negates one of the key aspects of the bailout program. It is supposed to move fast to stay ahead of the national liquidity crisis.

Paulson may be asking to change that. According to The Wall Street Journal, "The Treasury Department, signaling a new phase in its $700 billion financial-rescue plan, is considering requiring that firms seeking future government money raise private capital in order to qualify for public assistance."

While it may seem sensible to get smaller banks and insurance companies, the next group of firms likely to get Treasury help, to ask private investors to come in side-by-side with the government, the program would be flawed for two reasons.

The first is that, in a failing economy, nothing may bring private equity out of its shell even if buying into a financial firm getting a huge slug of government money might seem attractive in normal times. But, these are not normal times and panic keeps capital from making investments which should appear attractive.

The second reason that the plan is flawed is the private equity deals can take many weeks or even months to close, and private investors may want different terms than the federal government is getting. That turns what could be a quickly fashioned lifeline from Treasury into a prolonged process which could damage the companies it seeks to save.

It is probably a good thing that Paulson's tenure is over in two months. His new plan could could wreck what it is trying to fix.

Douglas A. McIntyre is an editor at 24/7 Wall St.