MassMutual became the latest big investor to admit losing money because of Bernard Madoff.According to Wall Street Journal, the company's Tremont Financial Group lost $3 billion -- more than half of its assets -- because of Madoff's $50 billion scam. Then there's the problem of disclosure.
"Tremont marketing documents did not always disclose the relationship between Mr. Madoff and the feeder funds, even when mentioning other investment managers," the paper said.
So let me get this straight: MassMutual entrusted some of its investors' money to one of the supposed geniuses of Wall Street and did not want anyone to know? Maybe the company did not want its customers to know that it was collecting fees that it did not really earn. I suspect many aggrieved investors will sue. I sympathize with their plight, ,but I do not feel sorry for people who invested with Madoff directly.
Many Madoff customers turned a blind eye to many red flags that should have sent them running for the hills. First of all, no one understood the Madoff's "investing philosophy." Questions about his strategy went unanswered.
They, like many victims of Ponzi schemes, figured that if Steven Spielberg, Yeshiva University and a host of other Wall Street bigshots liked this guy Madoff, he must be alright. They believed that Madoff never had a down year even during down markets, which even people who don't know the difference between a stock and a bond know is impossible.
The scheme was ingenious. The low double-digit returns Madoff showed were believable enough to fool most investors. His fraud only unraveled when people started to ask for their money because of the volatile stock market.
Because of its duration, odds are that Madoff is not telling the truth that he acted alone. Ponzi scheme organizers usually take the rap themselves to avoid getting their family members in trouble. His sons have said they knew nothing about the scheme. Authorities are probing the relationship between Madoff's niece Shana and a former SEC attorney, according to the Journal.
The Madoff scandal offers an important lesson for investors courtesy of our mothers: if it seems too good to be true, chances are that it is.
The Money Man Behind Rick Santorum: Who Is Foster S. Friess?
Savings Experiment: Snow Removal


Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
12-22-2008 @ 9:10PM
Richard Diskin said...
By Madoff having his family turn him in he thinks the SEC/Govt is to stupid to recognize his family as co-conspirators. I feel so sorry for him having to hole up in his apartment while out on bail. What a joke. How about CNN's top ten rip-off artists, lets not forget them. Nothing infuriates me more then when I read/hear about these so-called big execs getting bonuses. They all need to be locked up.
12-22-2008 @ 2:23PM
MyKisa said...
He got one of my customers for a million or more, nice guy, retired early because of health. He is in trouble now.
12-22-2008 @ 3:30PM
Dorian said...
A few years ago, there was a documentary where several famous con artists who had run various scams like these Ponzi schemes were interviewed. The one main point that they all made was this: It is almost impossible to get to someone who is not greedy. The hook they all use is greed. They said that someone who only wants a reasonable rate of return is a mark that they cannot convert to their program.
12-22-2008 @ 2:59PM
Tony said...
Investors that lost everything with Mr. Madoff put all their eggs in one basket. For this lack of conservative diversification it cost them their life savings. In a way it was their own greed that turned them away from properly diversifying their portfolio in favor of an almost guaranteed 1% monthly return. A lesson for all of us. It kind of like leaving your keys in the car and blaming the thief when its stolen.
12-22-2008 @ 3:03PM
BHarrison said...
The Madoff scandal offers an important lesson for investors courtesy of our mothers: "if it seems too good to be true, chances are that it is."
OK, this "lesson" has been said for so OFTEN for so long, that ANYONE who ignored this principle, then they literally "deserve to be taken to the cleaners".
The problem is that the invesment markets have become so intertwined and complex that "average investors" wind up having absolutely NO IDEA that they investments are involved in, and impacted by this massive Madoff FRAUD.
The fallout from the Madoff Ponzi scheme are going to result in people becoming aware of the REAL HIDDEN RISKS in investing in various "funds" and investment vehicles. This is going to result in a FURTHER SUBSTANTIAL RELUCTANCE to invest in such funds/ investment groups . . . and will result in the loss of many employment positions with these types of companies.
That will also significantly impact our overall economic activity . . . people are going to be much more cautious with their investments . . . economic activity is going to slow down appreciably.
As is said: "For every 'Loser' there is a 'Winner' . . . someone WAS paid for those investments that have now gone bad . . . the "wealth has been redistributed somewhat,", right? (Of course the CEOs, and corporate management have skimmed off a lot of these monies in the compensation packages worth HUNDREDS of MILLIONS of dollars INDIVIDUALLY.)
So, a lot of the money is "still out there", somewhwere, with someone; it just isn't being "circulated'; and the average American's dispoasable descretionary income has virtually disappeared. Who has the money??? And what will it take to get this money "circulated"???
12-22-2008 @ 4:25PM
dan said...
He would already been executed if he was in china...done deal, over, kaput.
12-22-2008 @ 3:08PM
Duke and duke said...
I wonder how many more ponzi schemes are out there lurking around and will eventually fall. The punishment for Bernie Madoff has not even been invented yet. That must have all been money on paper and not in reality. Where is some of that money? Does Bernie have it in a Swiss bank account or some other obscure place? Remember investment ponzi schemers, that if the economy falls you will get caught just like Skilling, Ley, and other players that bilked other peoples money. Wall Street has now gotten a rotten reputation. Put your money under a mattress. There is no interest on it anyway, and Wall Street can't find companies worth invesing in since companies are falling like dominoes anyway.
12-22-2008 @ 3:35PM
widollar said...
Uncle Bernie is their really an Easter Bunny? How about Santa Claus Uncle Bernie?
12-22-2008 @ 3:39PM
Just Thinking said...
You take the advice it is too good to be true --- so you don't invest in Madoff. You also diversify your holdings, investing in Companies A, B, & C --- However, Companies A, B, & C have invested in Madoff --- It is "Good Bye Retirement." [See Article esp. para. 4, It states: "So let me get this straight: MassMutual entrusted some of its investors' money to one of the supposed geniuses of Wall Street and did not want anyone to know? Maybe the company did not want its customers to know that it was collecting fees..."]
12-22-2008 @ 3:43PM
Richard said...
Is it my imagination or are most of the names that pop up in this Madoff circle-jerk of Irish extraction?
12-22-2008 @ 3:45PM
BBOB said...
GREED IS A WONDERFUL THING... IT WIPES OUT THE GREEDY..I DONT FEEL SORRY FOR ANY OF THEM
12-22-2008 @ 3:48PM
Jim said...
They knew what this guy was doing had some red flags. From my understanding the flags where large and many of them. The fund was too good to be real. Please do not feel bad for many of these people for they used them as a tax shelter for so many "foundations" to hide many from taxes. For those older people who put everything they had on the advice from one of his friends and lost everything I feel bad for and they truly should get their money back first if there is any to give out. If the goverment is going to do a bail out for this I think I will puke. Remember investing is a gamble no matter what. I just lost $2000.00 at the casino will they bail me out. (I expected to loose the money prior to going to the casino - had alot of fun while I watched those black chips go bye bye)
12-22-2008 @ 4:00PM
BELLCORD said...
AS A MODEST SUGGESTION MAY BERNIE BE GIVEN A 'WRIST SLAP' PUNISHMENT....IN THIS CASE A WRIST SLAP WOULD INCLUDE BURNING HIS HOUSE DOWN , SELLING HIS ENTIRE IMMEDIATE FAMILY INTO SLAVERY AND HIM BEING ENCASED IN A 55 GALLON BARREL OF HOG EXCREMENT WITH HEAD PROTRUDING FOR 12 HOURS DAILY AT BROAD AND WALL STREET FOR A PERIOD OF 2 YEARS. IF HE DOES IT AGAIN WE'LL BE FORCED TO EMPLOY LESS ENLIGHTEN PUNISHMENTS ...
12-22-2008 @ 4:20PM
bald skull said...
i honestly think his crime should be punishable by death. yes, i believe he (and any other upper management who he colluded with) should be executed for the crimes they've committed.
12-22-2008 @ 4:22PM
kathy said...
Madoff scandal? thought ponzi scheme...illegal?
12-22-2008 @ 4:23PM
BHarrison said...
More and more, I hear the projections that the stock markets will NOT be profitable throuh the year 2010 . . . it's just going to take that long for everything to settle out and "hit bottom".
The longer the FIs and corporations hide their losses and drag these matters out, the longer it will take for everything to "bottom out". Of course if they admitted to the truth (as they should be being required to do) many of the CEOs would be thrown out of their positions, and probably indicted . . . that is why they are dragging their feet on revealing the truth. But it is the "recovery" that is suffering from all of this.
The FACT is that everything has to "bottom out" in order for a recovery to start.
The government should begin to make crimnal indictments of those CEOs who have been concealing losses in their corporations.
12-22-2008 @ 5:49PM
Kathy said...
Rich, we Irish do not have the $$$
12-22-2008 @ 4:31PM
Tom Smaha said...
Just a poor country boy trying to make a living and putting monies aside for a comfortable retirement. Along comes this pathetic creep and many of us are now going to suffer. What will happen to him? Slap on the wrist, some time sitting in a federal prison (doubtful). Hopefully maybe Patrick Fitzgerald will look into his actions and take him down like he did the Govenors of Illinois.
12-22-2008 @ 4:35PM
bill said...
The entire market is a ponzi scheme, Madoff had great teachers!
12-22-2008 @ 4:34PM
Roland C. Woodak said...
REPUBLICAN MIDGETS MARCH TO SONG !
Heigh Ho! Heigh Ho!
It's off to deregulate we go!
Heigh Ho! Heigh Ho!
We'll screw friend and foe !
Roland C. Woodaka
(Limited Poetic Talent)!