Tonight I am appearing on a Boston TV program to discuss whether there are other Madoff disasters lurking as well as eight lessons from 2008. The first half of the program will feature Congressman Barney Frank (D-MA) who chairs the House Financial Services Committee.
The TV producer suggested that I should give Congressman Frank some thoughts about how to fix the financial services industry if I get a chance to talk with him in the green room before the show starts. I am not sure whether I will get to do this or not; however, here are four ideas I will share if I get the chance:
-
Limit leverage. Starting with an SEC ruling in 2004, banks could borrow as much as they wanted -- in some cases over $30 for every $1 of equity. This borrowing has endangered the global financial system. Washington should limit leverage to 8:1 or less.
-
Put banker pay in escrow. As I posted, banks should not pay bankers to close big deals and then let them keep the bonuses after the deals fall apart. Instead, they should do what Morgan Stanley (NYSE: MS) is starting to do, which is to put the bonuses in an escrow account -- if the deals lose money in the years following the contract signing, the money goes to pay off the investors. Otherwise, they get to keep the money.
-
Demand independent financial reporting. As I posted, we could prevent much financial fraud by creating an independent group of people who produce financial statements for companies and investment funds. This group would consist of talented and motivated auditors who were paid by the government and were financially independent of the organizations they audit.
-
End securitization. The practice of buying, credit-rating, and packaging loans into securities is a disaster. The result is securities that are so complex that nobody can put a value on them. The same is true for another branch of finance -- credit default swaps. These practices should be banned because they bet the entire global financial system on computer models that inevitably fail to predict the future catastrophe they cause.
I have one more idea which is probably beyond Washington's power to influence: As long as the smartest people in the world flock to Wall Street for the biggest bucks, the rest of society will continue to be at the mercy of the finance industry. If we could find a way to channel that talent to higher causes -- such as making the U.S. energy independent -- that would be great.
If you want to add anything to the list of thoughts for Congressman Frank, please comment below.
Peter Cohan is President of Peter S. Cohan & Associates. He also teaches management at Babson College. Portfolio published his eighth book, You Can't Order Change: Lessons From Jim McNerney's Turnaround at Boeing, on December 26, 2008.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
12-30-2008 @ 10:38AM
Richard Miller said...
I believe that hedge funds need to be held to same standards as any investment funds. They played havic with all commodity prices this past year and they have taken advantage of the commodity market, not as was originated.
Also there needs better enforcement of short selling.
12-29-2008 @ 7:15PM
DON said...
WHAT I WOULD TELL HIM IF I HAD THE CHANCE WOULD BE FOR HIM TO RETIRE AND GO FISHING BECOUSE HE KNOWS NOTHING ELSE
12-29-2008 @ 8:39PM
everysandwich said...
The idea of Mr. Frank, who said he thought Fannie and Freddie were sound, discussing next steps is a tad terrifying.
12-29-2008 @ 9:39PM
Al said...
Hey Barney,
How about raising the Capital Loss deduction for individuals so that we can deduct all of our individual financial losses in a shorter period of time. At the current 3k per year IRS limit, many taxpayers won't use it up during their lifetime. Yet Corporations get to deduct it immediately. How about a small bailout for the average individual investor? Please RAISE THE CAPITAL LOSS DEDUCTION TO AT LEAST 10K PER YEAR.
12-29-2008 @ 11:16PM
vince demarco said...
Mr.Frank,sir.To regain some control and confidence over the financial disaster produced on your watch,I propose the following:Either nationalize the auto,banking insurance and housing industry or let them all enter chapter 11 and sort themselves out.There is sufficient talent and money out there such that they would recover from chapt 11 as viable enterprises.
12-29-2008 @ 11:40PM
John said...
Barney Frank makes me ill. Pompous, arrogant, and self serving, with no apparent substance. The perfect lifetime congressman from massachusetts.
12-30-2008 @ 12:36AM
BHarrison said...
Isn't Barney Frank the epitome of the root cause of this financial emlt down. Wasn't it Mr. Frank who VEHEMENT FOUGHT AGAINST and VOTED AGAINST implementing any "level of regulation and oversight" of Frannie, Freddies, etc.?
In my personal opinion, I firmly believe that Barney Frank is the epitome of the CORRUPTION in Congress that has enabled and perpetuated the economic and business practices that have led to this entire debacle. How can Barney Frank possibly contribute ANYTHING CONSTRUCTIVE to the recovery efforts. Barney Frank is CORRUPTION PERSONIFIED.
12-30-2008 @ 2:20AM
greg said...
I would love to tell Rep. Frank that if the banks insist on "not telling" the taxpayers what they did with that bailout money, then any bank that received these bailout funds will find themselves assessed a special tax that would amount to a 90% tax rate.
Oh, and since these banks can borrow from the Fed at 0%, insist these "bailout barons" cut their credit card interest rates to a MAXIMUM of 12% for ANY customer.
12-30-2008 @ 6:23AM
BHarrison said...
Congress is the primary CULPRIT in the economic problems of the USA. They basically "sold out" to the special interests groups . . . and Barney Frank was one of the worst Of the Congressmen in regard to this issue.
Reportedly his "boy friend" or "significant 'other'" held a high paying job at Fannie Mae at the time that Frank VEHEMENTLY FOUGHT AGAINST regulation and oversight of Fannie, Freddie, etc.
Frank is a stumbling,bumbling buffoon; the people of MA need to have a recall election to replace the guy. He simply is not competent to be a Congressman.
12-30-2008 @ 8:48AM
Bendz said...
Hi,
Wish U A Happy New Year 2009 ;)
Insurance Agent
12-30-2008 @ 8:49AM
FRANK SCALF said...
BARNEY FRANK
WHAT A JOKE
12-30-2008 @ 10:04AM
JCH said...
At the time Frank said F&F were sound, 2003, they were sound. So was Bear Stearns. So was Lehman, etc.
That was before GWB administration and his drunken lunatic buddies in private industry had finished screwing up the world.