Boeing Co. (NYSE: BA) CEO, Jim McNerney, is managing a 159,300 employee aircraft manufacturer with $66.4 billion in sales and $4 billion in profits (both 2007 figures). If you're running a small business or aspire to start one, is there anything you can learn from McNerney that could help you achieve your business goals? Yes.
Portfolio is publishing my eighth book, You Can't Order Change, which studies how McNerney manages Boeing. To write this book I interviewed people who worked with McNerney and scrutinized how he manages people, strategy, operations, and communities. What I discovered is that McNerney has come up with very effective techniques for addressing 11 common CEO challenges.
Though McNerney is far from perfect -- for example, Boeing's popular 787 Dreamliner is two years behind schedule -- here are six such techniques that I think are the most useful to small business leaders:
- Make your people 15% better. McNerney motivates people to get 15% better every year -- and in so doing, boosts financial performance. Specifically, he focuses on people who have the potential to change due to their openness, courage, and teamwork. And he views his job as removing the bureaucratic obstacles that keep them from "igniting." To get there, he encourages the flow of information up and down the line. He gets phenomenally talented jerks out of the line, and he invests in leadership development.
- Lead groups to higher ground. McNerney finds common aims for groups both inside and outside the company that have traditionally competed with each other. For example, he can take a team of people from different functions and say, "Here are 10 possible strategies. We're not leaving this room until we all agree on which one we're going to follow." Then McNerney gives people the authority to exercise their intellectual freedom. He encourages them to speak their minds. He demands debate. He lets them express their opinions without fear of retaliation. When the team implements the strategy, it does so with enthusiasm because it feels ownership.
- Link pay to profit and process, not stock price. McNerney has instituted a subtle but important shift in the way managers at Boeing are paid. He recognizes that managers can't control Boeing's stock price, so he has increased the proportion of their bonuses linked to what managers can control -- their organization's profit. His notion is that the best business leaders make efficient use of the company's capital. For example, it's better for a business unit to earn $100 million of profit using $10 million of capital than to generate that same $100 million in profit but requiring $50 million of capital to get there. By measuring leaders on efficient use of capital, rather than boosting stock price, McNerney gets them to take responsibility for factors they can control; he eliminates their chance to make excuses for not performing; and he encourages them to pursue strategies that produce long-term value
- Tackle challenging situations quickly and effectively. McNerney filters hundreds of problems and opportunities down to the critical few within a period of months after taking on a new position. For instance, at GE Aircraft Engines he quickly figured out that his business plan would be at risk unless his team could figure out a way to stop competitors from making lower priced versions of its profitable spare engine parts. He assembled a team of patent attorneys, engineers, and manufacturing experts to develop and build a more advanced, patent-protected line of spare parts that would be tough for competitors to knock off. McNerney boosts the careers of people who support these solutions to high priority problems. And lets those who can't adapt go. For a new or aspiring manager, McNerney's ability to get his hands around a new operation quickly offers a useful model.
- Build strategy on customer focus. McNerney gets engineers to listen to the customer. By listening to passengers' fear of confinement and the discomfort of jet lag and by understanding airlines' changing route strategies, McNerney encouraged Boeing's product development teams to use composite technology as part of a design that would make customers happier. McNerney manages innovation so it yields products whose benefits make customers eager to buy. For anyone who works with an internal or external customer, McNerney's approach to building strategy can help lead to successful new products and processes.
- Tighten operations with process improvement tools. When McNerney wanted to improve productivity at 3M and Boeing, he used distinct methods at each. He boosted 3M's margins from 17% in 2001 to 23% in 2005 using Six Sigma, a process for cutting out waste used at GE. And at Boeing he used Lean Manufacturing -- another productivity enhancement tool -- to cut in half the time it takes to assemble a 737, from 22 days to 11 days, to save hundreds of millions of dollars, and to increase capacity without adding new plant. While not every small business is in a position to recommend and apply such productivity tools, McNerney's example illustrates their value when costs need to be cut.
These six techniques could be useful to a small business, and Jim McNerney uses five others which could be just as useful. My new book describes each technique and provides examples of how McNerney used them to improve performance. And that's a goal that any business executive hopes to accomplish.
Peter Cohan is president of Peter S. Cohan & Associates. He also teaches management at Babson College. His eighth book is You Can't Order Change: Lessons from Jim McNerney's Turnaround at Boeing. He has no financial interest in Boeing securities.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
1-05-2009 @ 12:48PM
Jay Ross said...
On Boeing: this CEO is another incompetentent that can run the CO. in spite of himself. They are beyond schedules and with a lot of waste, but they survive because the unique Technologies. THis CEO should be fired
he is full of shit...and about giving advice is very cheap when you can tap on billions of dollars. Article rating: pure bullshit
1-05-2009 @ 1:51PM
mady said...
Who is Jay Ross? You can't argue with success.
No business runs without problems. At Least they are not asking for a handout. Too many CEO'S are planning their next trip or golf outing, instead of tendng to business. The auto Industry might learn something. The workers and customers might be able to give them some ideas.
1-05-2009 @ 2:47PM
crossrdsales said...
I totally agree with Jay. Boeing is over a year late on production of the 787 Dreamliner, lost six months of production due to a machinists strike, is losing customers to Airbus due to delays of the 787, and has outsourced a ton of their key components and sub-assemblies to suppliers overseas (mainly China). Just last month China successfully launched their maiden flight of a cargo plane that competes directly with Boeing's, and they're now on schedule to come out with their own passenger jets by 2012-2015.
So, how smart can this guy be when he's literally cost Boeing billions in lost revenues due to production delays, suffered unnecessary set backs in production by fighting for pennies with the machinists when dollars were flying out the window, and outsourced the production of key parts to Chinese suppliers who were the cause of many of Boeings production delays and who now understand how to build a competing airplane of their own. They're following the exact same model the Japanese companies did back in the 70s and 80s. Let the stupid American companies teach us how to make everything and then when we don't need them anymore we'll build our own competing products.
I agree with Jay that McNerney, like many of our Fortune 500 CEOs, unfortunately, is an overpaid, underperforming executive who everybody pays homage to because he's the CEO of a big company. Sad, but this is what many of our US companies have come to. Run by incompetent, greedy, egomaniacs pushing them to the brink of bankruptcy or worse.
1-05-2009 @ 8:03PM
John said...
As a small business owner I can see where some of his ideas might work under the right circumstances, and with enough capital to do it. But in the real world of small business there is not enough profit to impliment these ideas, or the man power. I have dealt with many large companies in my time an GE is not a smart company. Their paying out tons of moey for stuff that is most times not there, or I should say they pay twice and sometimes three times for the same thing, an there is no way to get the moeny back. Or they run their supliers around to the point where they will no longer do business with them. CEO equals Completely Ego Oriented..
1-05-2009 @ 5:56PM
MyKisa said...
AFLACs ceo is very well grounded in sound policy.
1-05-2009 @ 6:01PM
John S. Mournian said...
This BOEING hotshot is out of place! Get BA out of Chicago and back to its roots, place the load of success on Americans and only their most trusted and faithful partners; i.e., Japan, England and maybe a few others. The pay of a CEO should be desided by a more practical formula that does not rob shareholders who a captive partners. Mr. McNerney is just a bit better than those before him and that is not much!
Smokescreen
Yes! I won a business and I have international
customers in 28 countries.
1-05-2009 @ 6:12PM
Biz Improvement Guy said...
The statements made by the author of the article that small businesses may not be able to use / apply tools to reduce variation (six sigma) and waste (lean manufacturing) shows to me that he knows little, if anything, about process improvement tools and methods. I would say this calls into question the validity of his article and books. Sounds like another academician without any practical experience in the real world of business, telling others how to run (ruin?) their business.
1-05-2009 @ 7:22PM
Ed Murphy said...
Some of the facts offered by other readers are a healthy balance to the piece, although there are some good concepts that can be applied to most businesses. My issue with Boeing is their failure, after spending $5 billion of taxpayer money, to build a large, coordinated satellite imaging and communication system that (in my opinion) could have been deployed to constantly monitor the placement of roadside bombs in Iraq and save many soldiers' lives and maiming injuries.
1-05-2009 @ 9:26PM
Jim said...
Do Not know much but is he turning a profit in these times of challenge for most companies. But if he is what is wrong with his leadership? If this guy is turning a profit and working hard with strong managers, leadership and all making money while working damb hard is great.
1-07-2009 @ 3:46AM
CHOPS said...
SO WHAT THE FEY? HOW HARD IS IT TO BE A CEO. YOU HAVE VP'S FOR EVERYTHING AND YOU PUT ALL THE BLAME ON THEM. VP-SALES-INCREASE SALES BY 10% THIS YEAR. VP-OPERATIONS-CUT COSTS BY 10% THIS YEAR, VP-MARKETING-COME UP WITH 10% MORE CREATIVE ADVERTISING THIS YEAR. AND IF THEY DON'T THEN NEXT YEAR IT THEY ARE FIRED AND THE ASSISTANT VP MOVES UP.
1-06-2009 @ 7:37PM
Brandon Allen said...
The title small biz tips from a CEO gives me pause to start. Most C level executives at large corporations are way out of touch with what small business needs to be successful. His tips evidence that for sure. The lack of support for this article by the preceding commenters shows that this advice will not resonate with true entrepreneurs.
1-11-2009 @ 9:17AM
Brett said...
The idea of a CEO getting credit for all the work he did not do. Is one of the sickest in America. CEO are the boss. They say it was my great leadership when things get done correct. When things go bad. CEO fires and blame others. This guy says trick workers into feeling like they have ownership. There will be a day when CEO will not be needed. When worker organize and own there own company. No CEO will be able to compete with the worker owned businesses of the future.
1-11-2009 @ 11:06AM
Jim Copeland said...
He should get together with that other skumbag of industry Jack Welch AKA
Neutron Jack They could write a big thick book based on all of thier Bullshit! My advise as a former succesfull small business man! Is that what ever they say, Just do the opposit and you will come out on top! Tricking the employees? What an asshole! JC
1-11-2009 @ 4:16PM
Ron said...
More "amazing platitudes" to live by ..
Most corporate-types surround themselves with "yes sir" people to tell them how wonderful they are and will always be when their decisions are implemented, whether they work or not. The results will be "polished", "news-managed", "politically-enhanced", run through all the necessary "filters" and sent to all the media lapdogs ..the same bunch who skews all the "news" you read in your local papers. That is the real bottom line, folks.
1-11-2009 @ 4:47PM
Clint said...
Completely bogus article full of crap ... any CEO with that many V.P.'s and billions of dollars can say whatever ... obviously Boeing has serious problems the author never investigated. Waste of time reading this garbage.
1-12-2009 @ 12:41AM
AeroGuy said...
The 2008 strike was 57 days long ..
Boeing calculated it was losing $100 MILLION PER DAY while that strike lasted.
Is that a great executive decision or what ? GIve me a break !!!
Excessive outsourcing of major components to foreign countries gave away priceless American technical knowledge ..another great executive idea ?
Letting so many other sub-contractors in on the airplane parts-building gave away control of the product and caused many technical glitches and bad parts that would not fit properly. Yet another wonderful decision ?
Hyping, developing (at huge taxpayer-funded subsidies) the in-flight internet ..then abandoning it. Smart one ?
SMALL BIZ people have to make SMART, RATIONAL, LOGICAL, FISCALLY-PRUDENT decisons on a day-by-day basis or the bottom-line wipes out and they are out-of-business. Huge corporations just suck up to government--provided grants, development requests, and special tax-reduction deals through their ever-present political connections with Senators, Congressional Reps and Governors.
Your dollars at work ?
1-12-2009 @ 7:34AM
Biz Improvement Guy said...
The title of Cohan's book should be "Thriving on Mediocrity: How Companies Make Money in Spite of Management's Bad Decisions."
1-13-2009 @ 5:26PM
mike said...
HERES A BILL YOU CAN ACTUALLY MAKE LOWER.YOUR ELECTRIC BILL IN TEXAS AND NEW YORK AND YOUR NATURAL GAS BILL IN NEW YORK AND ILLINOIS.ITS DUE TO THE DEREGULATION OF ENERGY COMPANYS.IT COSTS YOU NOTHING AND NOTHING CHANGES FOR YOU THE CUSTOMER.YOU ARE STILL SERVICED BY YOUR CURRENT COMPANY,STILL BILLED BY YOUR CURRENT COMPANY.REFER 15 OTHER CUSTOMERS AND GET FREE ELECTRIC.WHAT DOES YOUR COMPANY OFFER YOU? GO TO www.mzimmet.joinambit.com start saving money.you are entitled to it so why not take advantage of it.
1-19-2009 @ 6:46AM
George said...
It is OK if the government is funding you no matter what it costs. Their ABM was a flop and the government put billions into that. The 787 is waaaaayyyy behind. There might be a challenge in keeping that many people heading in the same direction at one time, but I see nothing exceptional here. That is why Airbus came from nothing to become Boeing's equal.
1-19-2009 @ 1:42PM
LEETRAF said...
IT IS A LOT OF CRAP. ASSEMBLE THE 787 IN 11 DAYS INSTEAD OF 22. BULL. MOST OF THE PARTS COME FROM OUT OF USA. CUT HIS PAY AND HE COULD PUT MORE INTO TO COMPANY. OVER RUNS ARE JUST PICKED UP BY THE TAX PAYER. WHO IS THIS GUY KIDDING?