Welcome to the 102nd installment of The Wal-Mart Weekly, a column dedicated to bringing you insight, wit, facts, results, opinions, and just a bit of everything else when it comes to a very hot topic these days: Wal-Mart.
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. (NYSE: WMT) has had one big, black eye in recent time that it just can't get away from: its relationship with labor. Wal-Mart's fiercest critics have pointed out many examples of the low pay, pricey health insurance, and low-end working conditions.
Are Wal-Mart workers really in that big of a bind, or does the largest retailer in the world have pay and benefit parity with all its competitors? When you're the biggest, you have the target painted on your back -- and Wal-Mart has been there for some time. However, the company has just announced a rather large bonus plan for its employees with a sizable target indeed: $2 billion dollars.
Hourly employees get a lift
One could say that Wal-Mart employees (mostly hourly) get the market rate for the jobs they perform. After all, do Kroger and Target employees enjoy a huge wage increase over their Wal-Mart worker friends? Doubtful. While Wal-Mart is the first to point out that it pays its employees well, many employees have taken the victim route and have joined the critics' circles. These critics state that Wal-Mart employees just can't get by with the low wages the retailer pays. In a country where almost everyone can have a choice to work, this entitlement mentality runs rampant in the Wal-Mart bashing industry.
On the flip side, those who claim many Wal-Mart employees are "forced" to work there or somehow be homeless (or the equivalent) take up the cause for trying to get the retailer to pay wages that would give workers a living wage. While "living wage" is a completely relative term, the basic needs should be covered: shelter, food and medical. If those three needs are not met sufficiently with a job's wages, then there's a problem. What to do?
Wal-Mart is raking in the dough
While many (if not almost all) retailers are struggling heavily through the current recession, Wal-Mart is the one who is growing and making money. The reason, which has been discussed ad nauseam in the last three months, is due to many millions of retail consumers "trading down" to get the best prices on everything they need every day, from tires to food to light bulbs.
As such, Wal-Mart will be shortly rewarding many of those store-level employees with cash bonuses. The total being given out? About $2 billion, according to the retailer. The bonuses won't just come in the form of cash, though: pension savings accounts are also included. While many retailers and companies have suspended matching 401k contributions in light of the economic crisis underway, Wal-Mart is increasing contributions using these bonuses.
The breakdown as given by CEO Mike Duke:
- $933.6 million in cash bonuses
- $788.8 million in profit-sharing and pension contributions
- Merchandise discounts and contributions to its employee stock purchase plan
Why the open wallets?
At a time when the movement to unionize as many Wal-Mart locations as possible is underway, is Wal-Mart's increasing generosity indicative of an ulterior motive, or is it really part of a plan to share the corporate wealth to its employee base? We again have to think about whether Wal-Mart's worker treatment (pay and benefits) is on par with the competition's. Should Wal-Mart be held to a higher standard than its competition based on its standing of being the largest retailer on the face of the planet? If so, why?
Wal-Mart critics will surely see the retailer's bonus tactic here as a ruse intended to guide attention from potential collective bargaining movements. Wal-Mart workers, on the other hand, will welcome the bonus in all its forms with open arms. One thing remains clear: while large corporations are taking federal taxpayer money in the form of bailouts and paying large bonuses to executives and sending millions down the "perk" hole, Wal-Mart is giving back to its workers -- the exact opposite of the incredible greed currently gripping incompetently-ran, brink-like companies like AIG. That alone stands for something, and Wal-Mart's fiercest critics can't shake a stick at that.
Join me right here this time next week for another edition of the Wal-Mart Weekly. Until then, stay safe and keep your wallets and purses protected.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
3-23-2009 @ 7:04PM
CHARLIE SORG said...
its not all about money either , its about workers having to cover to much area, unload trucks, stock and do displays , how many times have we gone to a walmart and cant find help in sporting goods or any area at times ive actually left the store and went somewhere else and its not the employees fault its the selfish greedy store managers who get bigger bonus if they can run the store on the least amount of people and the least amount of hours, walmarts could have made even more billions had they had enough people to cover all the areas in there store ..everyone i know and have talked to fully agree with me on this one.. so my advise for walmart is hire more workers and watch your profits rise even more ..stop the greed its still there in management change there bonus systems..
3-23-2009 @ 8:06PM
me said...
Well the Walmart in Clanton Alabama does not stock anything. One reason i shop at walmart is for the convience of everything. I quit shopping there because they are always out of everthing.
3-23-2009 @ 8:07PM
sjdemar2 said...
A $50.00 bonus to each employee, wow thank you, get real. Do you think people are stupid talk about greed, Wal-Mart helps no one except themselves. I would respect you more if you were honest about who you are rather than trying to shade it!
3-23-2009 @ 11:07PM
NALA said...
CONGRATULATIONS ! WALMART
IS MY FAVORITE STORE, I LOVE THE GOOD PRICES AND ALL THE GOOD THINGS THERE.
SO PLEASE NO UNIONS .
YOU ARE DOING GREAT !!!.
3-24-2009 @ 1:05AM
Fran Pipkin said...
Our employees managed to get $85 for their hard work this quarter. We had a million dollar black friday, the first time we ever made that much. Almost seems like a slap in the face to see such a paltry amount for a bonus. Maybe if we didn't have to pay bonuses for 20 managers we would've gotten a little more.
3-24-2009 @ 2:00AM
Farhan Khan said...
Well I read an article The Good Prices And All The Good Things There.walmarts could have made even more billions had they had enough people to cover all the areas in there store. so my advise for walmart is hire more workers and watch your profits rise even more. http://www.stockpickernewsletter.com/
3-25-2009 @ 6:51AM
thbirdrock said...
I live in a small city (30k) east of Tampa Fl. Our local W/M is a clean,friendly place to shop. imo out of stock items are due to new customers, My employer has been a WM supplier for yrs. in perishables. WM's inv. control and dist model has knocked the "good ol grocery folks"off their perch. For those who feel the"non-contract" bonus' to be"too paltry" sounds to me you expected a "Malibu Barbie" and the "beanie baby wasn't enough.
3-26-2009 @ 11:23AM
roudy11z said...
I have read the comments on this article and especiall noticed #3 SJEMAR 2. I respond to it by saying I have talked to some WMT employees that got this bonus. One of them bought a new washer and dryer,one bought a new LCD tv and I could go on. How did they do that with only a $50 bonus?? Maybe #3 will answer this. RoudMan
4-02-2009 @ 4:55PM
roudy11z said...
I just have to add that today I talked to a Wal-Mart hourly employee and he said his bonus was enough for him to make 4 car payments.This is obviously more than $50 dollars. He said he has worked for them 6 years. Some of the other comments made here don't include the "BIG PICTURE" or they can't see the "forest for the trees" maybe? RoudMan
4-04-2009 @ 12:20PM
den said...
I work for a Wal*Mart in Ohio and the managers are the only people that make money. They promise you all kind of things when you are hired, but it is a load of crap. The bonuses do not even start until after your 6th month which means you could wait for up to 8 months before you even recreive a bonus. They pay out by the profit the store makes and by how many hours that you work. You have to work at least 11 hours a week to maintain any kind of 3 mth. bonus. Then they overload you to work different areas so they keep their workforce down in size to maintain profits and refuse to hire security in the store. I work at a very high crime are Wal* Mart and have never felt safe!!!
4-06-2009 @ 3:33PM
kevin said...
lol what bonus go union
4-09-2009 @ 1:38PM
coalitionofthesickandtired said...
It's great that Wal-mart decided to throw their employees a bone(however small it might be), however, that is like putting a band-aid on a gaping wound. The gap in wal-marts pay scale is one to make your jaw drop. Those of you that enjoy your cheap(and cheaply made) products...keep in mind that most of that comes from China, from a worker making 18 cents/hr just to let your greedy self get something for extremely cheap. When it comes to other businesses..how can you compete with someone that violates human rights on a hourly basis? You can't..unless you do it yourself..
Wal mart was able to provide well made-cheap products back when everything was made in the u.s.....so why can't they now? Because if they pay a chinese worker 18 cents/hr. They make loads more money..This is why they are not hurting in this economic downturn. Wake up people.
5-12-2009 @ 9:46AM
Sheri said...
Let's get this Wal-mart thing straight.My husband works for the mega giant.His "My Share Bonus" for a store that made 106% more than last year,and is considered a model store is $25.26.I doubt anyone can make 4 car payments with that kind of money.Stores are under staffed.Employees are pitched out the door to save money on hours paid.One employee is expected to perform the job of three,and get it done in half the time necessary.Management comes up with side jobs,such as construction within the store,with promises of extra pay or overtime which they quickly reverse once the job is complete.In this economy I'm happy he has a job,but Wal-marts boasting on excellent treatment of associates is just to much.My suggestion is Wal-mart needs to admit they have faults instead of propagating falsehoods.Employees would be happier knowing the truth instead of feeling screwed all the time.Mr. Walton would be disgusted with the way his company is being run.He said "I can run my company without managers,but not without associates";that quote is the first thing Wal-mart tells you when you are hired.Maybe a union would not be so bad considering the change in attitude since the loss of Mr. Walton.
6-29-2009 @ 11:26AM
Redwoodflyer said...
Hey den...if you feel so unsafe, QUIT!