James Altucher vs. Fred Wilson: Differing views on Internet investing


This weekend, financial writer and investor James Altucher published a controversial article, The Internet Is Dead (As An Investment), igniting a debate in the financial blogosphere by saying "...run for the hills when it comes to advising clients to invest in the Internet. The days of infinite margins, 1,000% productivity gains and growth of market throughout the universe are long over. Internet companies now should be treated, at best, like utility companies that get bought at about 10 times earnings and sold at 13 times earnings."

It's an interesting point of view from someone so heavily invested in this space. (Altucher is an investor and partner in Social Leverage that funds Web businesses including Bit.ly, Stocktwits, Tweetdeck and Ticketfly)

Fred Wilson responded on his blog with a post entitled, The Internet Is Alive And Well (As An Investment)
saying "We (my partners and I at Union Square Ventures) think the Internet is one of those transformative technologies that changes everything."
This blogger, money manager, and tech expert dealing with larger investments (than the average investor) through his firm Union Square Ventures can afford to dabble in multiple emerging Internet entities and expresses his positive view in a comment below his blog post, "I don't think the "easy money" has yet been made. The easy money will be made when the sector is well understood and all of these stocks become blue chips".

Altucher, the antagonist in this Internet battle, seemed to turn against his once optimistic view on Internet investing saying "Investment is about risk versus reward and the Internet for the past 15 years of investing has been largely a crapshoot."

Like most hedge fund strategies, startup Internet investing currently sits in the high-risk category. The big winners may be sold at 10-30x investors' initial capital, but the latter end up becoming financial black holes. You need to understand the difference between investing in start-ups and venture capital (VC) and publicly-traded companies in the stock market.

While Wilson defends the infancy and immense growth of this sector (and the variety of his Web-based investments), Altucher speaks to the public and average long-term investors as to the difficulty of picking big stock winners and winning-business models in large publicly traded Internet and media stocks like Time Warner Inc. (NYSE: TWX) and News Corp. (NYSE: NWS).

Despite the similarities, they are arguing apples to oranges.

The interconnectedness here of Altucher and Wilson is also interesting, as they are both active VC's in the Internet startup niche. Altucher is also on the board of directors of Betaworks backed-Bit.ly, which is now the official URL shortener of Wilson-backed Twitter. Through Social Leverage, Altucher is also invested in two other services built on top of Twitter, StockTwits & Tweetdeck.

This all goes to show there is no consensus whatsoever as to where the Internet is headed nor how to invest in this space either. Is this still just the beginning of the Internet revolution (as the usage numbers suggest) or are these largely profit-and-revenue-lacking businesses (as their fundamentals suggest) all sizzle and no steak? Time will tell...
Symbol Lookup
IndexesChangePrice
DJIA+5.7512,883.95
NASDAQ+11.782,915.86
S&P 500+2.911,349.96

Last updated: February 08, 2012: 11:30 PM

Hot Stocks

General Electric

19.24+0.06(+0.31)

Alcoa

10.670.00(0.00)

Apple Inc

476.68+7.85(+1.67)

Google Inc 'A'

609.85+3.08(+0.51)

Bank of America

8.13+0.28(+3.57)

Wal-Mart Stores

61.62-0.07(-0.11)

Exxon Mobil Corp

85.32-0.55(-0.64)

Ford

12.84-0.04(-0.31)

Citigroup

34.23+1.16(+3.51)

IBM

192.95+0.35(+0.18)

Yahoo

15.78-0.05(-0.32)

Starbucks

48.72+0.31(+0.64)

Microsoft

30.66+0.31(+1.02)

Home Depot

45.17-0.29(-0.64)

DailyFinance Headlines

Benzinga Headlines

TheFlyOnTheWall.com Headlines

BioHealth Investor Headlines

WalletPop Headlines

DailyFinance BlackBerry App

My Portfolios

Track your stocks here!

Find out why more people track their portfolios on AOL Money & Finance then anywhere else.

BloggingStocks Partners

More from AOL Money & Finance

BioHealth Investor Headlines

Page Loaded in 1328761819831 ms.