As Tracy Coenen discussed earlier, Overstock.com (NASDAQ: OSTK), co-founder, president and chief operating officer Jason Lindsey resigned and left the company's board of directors.

Lindsey had already retired once but came back, in CEO Patrick Byrne's own words, "when I screwed it up a couple years ago". Byrne added that "He's done a superb job. Now that it is back in a solid trailing twelve month cash-flow-positive position, he wishes to return to our previous arrangement. While Jason won't be as involved in the day-to-day operations of the company, he will still oversee special projects in a part-time capacity."

After Byrne's pat on the back and attaboys, the stock hit a new multi-year low in this morning's trading.

There are a few things to keep in mind here. As Gary Weiss wrote on his blog,

Lindsey says he is leaving because he is "ready to take a less active role in order to spend time on some outside ventures." Baloney. Note that he is leaving as director -- a position that surely requires no major heavy lifting in a board as supine as this one.

Sam Antar is also suspicious of the resignation that comes in the midst of an SEC investigation: "Was the SEC investigation of Overstock.com an undisclosed factor in Jason C. Lindsey's resignation?" Antar also discusses accounting questions surrounding Overstock.com, and comments from Mr. Lindsey on conference calls that raise questions about his involvement.

One thing's for sure: The market's reaction to Lindsey leaving doesn't suggest that traders buy Byrne's "everything is hunky dory" assertion that Lindsey left because he has restored the company to such great condition he is no longer needed in a full-time role.

Just after the close of the market Wednesday, Overstock.com (NASDAQ: OSTK) issued a press release announcing the departure of a top executive. Effective December 31, Jason Lindsey resigned as president and chief operating officer and left the board of directors. Lindsey was the third Overstock board member to resign in 2007.

This hurts, and observers can only wonder if this is a sign of the Overstock.com ship finally sinking under the direction of CEO Patrick Byrne. Byrne is known far and wide for his publicity stunts and various antics in the name of his pet projects, all the while his company is unable to turn a profit.

What's even more telling about this departure is that Lindsey helped found the company. Byrne is quoted, "When I screwed it up a couple years ago, he came out of retirement, and has played a decisive role getting it back on track." At least Byrne is finally willing to admit that he screwed up the company!