Office Depot (NYSE: ODP) is urging shareholders to reject the efforts of Levitt Corp. (NYSE: LEV) and Woodbridge Equity Fund to elect two of their nominees to the company's board of directors at the company's April 23rd annual meeting. The investors, who own about 1% of the company, are seeking to replace the company's current CEO and chairman and its former CEO and chairman; they have nominated the company's former COO and the former president of Staples (NYSE: SPLS) to replace them.

In a press release, the company said that it "believes that removing two of the most experienced retailing executives from the Office Depot Board would be highly disruptive, and could destabilize the Company and damage prospects for a successful turnaround. The Board has a strong long-range plan that is in the process of being implemented under difficult macroeconomic conditions."

As with many situations like this, the chart tells the story. Over the past 10 years, Office Depot has lost nearly 50% of its value while Staples has more than doubled in value. Obviously the current strategy is a failure, and the "experienced retailing executives" have destroyed billions of dollars in shareholder value. They might as well give someone else a shot and, if these directors should be opposed, the opposition shouldn't come from a board of directors with a horrendous track record.