Investors who have been following the ETF market in the last year have most certainly come across offerings from WisdomTree Investments (Other OTC: WSDT). After the stock's recent slide, in my opinion due to high naked short interest (the stock was on the Regulation SHO list for the fall) , I think the company's shares are starting to look interesting. But this isn't a traditional investment for most people -- the company trades on the pink sheets. However, I don't believe that should cause investors to stop looking at this company.
WisdomTree has essentially revolutionized the ETF industry by creating their own way of "weighing" indexes. While there is tremendous debate among both academics and financial professionals, WisdomTree's website is loaded with academic research and backtesting to justify its claims that their weighting methods are optimal. I highly recommend readers check out WisdomTree's website.
Unlike many companies trading on the pink sheets without financial filings, WisdomTree has voluntarily been making its financial filings public since 2005. Although these filings aren't pretty -- the company is losing money and not producing much revenues, I believe it says something about the company that they voluntarily file their information.
WisdomTree's products actually seem to be doing very well on both a return and assets under management basis despite being in operation for only a little more than one year. For example, WisdomTree's core offerings include:
- WisdomTree Dividend Index: $357 million under management
- WisdomTree DEFA Index: $393 million under management
- WisdomTree Interntaional Communications Sector Index: $390 million under management
- WisdomTree International Basic Materials Sector Index: $462 million under management
- WisdomTree International Utilities Sector Index: $375 million under management
- Wisdom Tree Pacific ex-Japan Index: $452 million under management
In addition, some of the company's more recent offerings -- the earnings-weighted products -- are also doing very well. Many of them are already in the $200-250 million AUM range despite only launching a couple months ago.
As you can see, the company has a rather significant asset base for a very young company. The company's products are also doing well. For information on their performance I recommend that you
view this video.
I really love the asset manager business model -- it's extraordinarily scalable and it's usually not a very capital intensive model. However, the way WisdomTree has launched with marketing, launching fees, and so on, is not typical for most money managers. That being said, I believe it creates a long term value for the company. An acquirer would receive more than 20 ETF listings with tried-and-true strategies, a much better proposition for most bigger asset managers or banks than buying a one-trick-pony hedge fund. I think that investors have to look out 2-3 years to see any potential value in this name. However, looking out to late 2008, I think the company will have nearly 40 ETF offerings and $7-10 billion in assets. If that's the case, I think the $440 million price-tag on the company today will look cheap because I've seen money managers bought out for 12-22% of AUM.
After speaking with my good friend and fellow writer Zac Bissonnette he raised the issue of ETF price wars that he expects to come as a result of Vanguard more aggressively entering the space which he covered here.While this is certainly a valid risk, I think it doesn't affect WisdomTree as much as it will affect major players like Barclay's with products that aren't unique or innovative.
There's one other potential catalyst: WisdomTree's goal to become listed on the NASDAQ. The company hopes to be listed on the NASDAQ. I don't think this is a distant goal -- the company already files audited financials and its management team is very "plugged-in." If the company does in fact get listed, WisdomTree will gain exposure and trust because it will no longer be traded amongst the pump-and-dump stocks of the pink sheets.
Add it all up and I think the risk-reward proposition is very interesting. While the stock is certainly speculative, I think the company has valuable, innovative and popular products that are going to continue to gain in popularity in coming years as investors realize the changes that different weightings can have on returns.